Optimization of a Picarro L2140-i cavity ring-down spectrometer for routine measurement of triple oxygen isotope ratios in meteoric waters

• Published in: Atmospheric measurement techniques Vol. 16; no. 6; pp. 1663 - 1682
• Main Authors: Hutchings, Jack A., Konecky, Bronwen L.
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Katlenburg-Lindau Copernicus GmbH 29.03.2023; Copernicus Publications
• Subjects: Alcohols; Analysis; Analytical errors; Analyzers; Best practice; Best practices; Cavity ringdown; Contamination; Corrections; Data analysis; Data processing; Diurnal variations; Error correction; Error reduction; Factorial experiments; Infrared analysis; Infrared lasers; Inlets (waterways); Instrument industry; Isotope ratios; Isotopes; Laser applications; Lasers; Mass spectrometry; Mass spectroscopy; Measurement; Meteoric water; Optimization; Organic contaminants; Oxygen; Oxygen isotope ratio; Oxygen isotopes; Performance evaluation; Rain; Rain water; Rainfall; Rainwater; Ratios; Scientific imaging; Troubleshooting
• DOI: 10.5194/amt-16-1663-2023
• ISSN: 1867-8548; 1867-1381

The demanding precision of triple oxygen isotope (Δ17O) analyses in water has restricted their measurement to dual-inlet mass spectrometry until the recent development of commercially available infrared laser analyzers. Laser-based measurements of triple oxygen isotope ratios are now increasingly performed by laboratories seeking to better constrain the source and history of meteoric waters. However, in practice, these measurements are subject to large analytical errors that remain poorly documented in scientific literature and by instrument manufacturers, which can effectively restrict the confident application of Δ17O to settings where variations are relatively large (∼ 25–60 per meg). We present our operating method of a Picarro L2140-i cavity ring-down spectrometer (CRDS) during the analysis of low-latitude rainwater where confidently resolving daily variations in Δ17O (differences of ∼ 10–20 per meg) was desired. Our approach was optimized over ∼ 3 years and uses a combination of published best practices plus additional steps to combat spectral contamination of trace amounts of dissolved organics, which, for Δ17O, emerges as a much more substantial problem than previously documented, even in pure rainwater. We resolve the extreme sensitivity of the Δ17O measurement to organics through their removal via Picarro's micro-combustion module, whose performance is evaluated in each sequence using alcohol-spiked standards. While correction for sample-to-sample memory and instrumental drift significantly improves traditional isotope metrics, these corrections have only a marginal impact (0–1 per meg error reduction) on Δ17O. Our post-processing scheme uses the analyzer's high-resolution data, which improves δ2H measurement (0.25 ‰ error reduction) and allows for much more rich troubleshooting and data processing compared to the default user-facing data output. In addition to competitive performance for traditional isotope metrics, we report a long-term, control standard root mean square error for Δ17O of 12 per meg. Overall performance (Δ17O error of 6 per meg, calculated by averaging three replicates spread across distinct, independently calibrated sequences) is comparable to mass spectrometry and requires only ∼ 6.3 h per sample. We demonstrate the impact of our approach using a rainfall dataset from Uganda and offer recommendations for other efforts that aim to measure meteoric Δ17O via CRDS.