A bibliometric mapping of shadow education research: achievements, limitations, and the future
This study aims to map the literature on shadow education using metadata extracted from 488 publications indexed in the Web of Science database. It is termed as shadow education because much of its content mimics what is learned in schools. The study uses bibliometric procedures to describe and visu...
Saved in:
| Published in | Asia Pacific education review Vol. 23; no. 2; pp. 341 - 359 |
|---|---|
| Main Authors | , |
| Format | Journal Article |
| Language | English |
| Published |
Dordrecht
Springer Netherlands
01.06.2022
Springer Springer Nature B.V 교육연구소 |
| Subjects | |
| Online Access | Get full text |
| ISSN | 1598-1037 1876-407X |
| DOI | 10.1007/s12564-022-09759-4 |
Cover
Loading…
| Abstract | This study aims to map the literature on shadow education using metadata extracted from 488 publications indexed in the Web of Science database. It is termed as shadow education because much of its content mimics what is learned in schools. The study uses bibliometric procedures to describe and visually represent available literature on shadow education in terms of main sources, key authors, institutions, and countries leading the production and dissemination of research on shadow education. Further, the study elaborates on h-classics publications to obtain an in-depth understanding of the most influential scientific outputs in this domain. Key findings of the study are that research on shadow education (a) has experienced steady growth over the last decade; (b) is disseminated through a wide range of outlets, mainly in the disciplines of sociology of education, economics of education, educational psychology, and language education; (c) is published mainly by scholars working in East Asia and the United States; (d) has focused on tangible (quantifiable) benefits related to improved examination results; and (e) reveals how this form of instruction primarily benefits students hailing from high socioeconomic backgrounds, thereby contributing to greater educational inequality. This study also suggests pedagogical implications and areas for ongoing research. |
|---|---|
| AbstractList | This study aims to map the literature on shadow education using metadata extracted from 488 publications indexed in the Web of Science database. It is termed as shadow education because much of its content mimics what is learned in schools. The study uses bibliometric procedures to describe and visually represent available literature on shadow education in terms of main sources, key authors, institutions, and countries leading the production and dissemination of research on shadow education. Further, the study elaborates on h-classics publications to obtain an in-depth understanding of the most influential scientific outputs in this domain. Key findings of the study are that research on shadow education (a) has experienced steady growth over the last decade; (b) is disseminated through a wide range of outlets, mainly in the disciplines of sociology of education, economics of education, educational psychology, and language education; (c) is published mainly by scholars working in East Asia and the United States; (d) has focused on tangible (quantifiable) benefits related to improved examination results; and (e) reveals how this form of instruction primarily benefits students hailing from high socioeconomic backgrounds, thereby contributing to greater educational inequality. This study also suggests pedagogical implications and areas for ongoing research. KCI Citation Count: 0 This study aims to map the literature on shadow education using metadata extracted from 488 publications indexed in the Web of Science database. It is termed as shadow education because much of its content mimics what is learned in schools. The study uses bibliometric procedures to describe and visually represent available literature on shadow education in terms of main sources, key authors, institutions, and countries leading the production and dissemination of research on shadow education. Further, the study elaborates on h-classics publications to obtain an in-depth understanding of the most influential scientific outputs in this domain. Key findings of the study are that research on shadow education (a) has experienced steady growth over the last decade; (b) is disseminated through a wide range of outlets, mainly in the disciplines of sociology of education, economics of education, educational psychology, and language education; (c) is published mainly by scholars working in East Asia and the United States; (d) has focused on tangible (quantifiable) benefits related to improved examination results; and (e) reveals how this form of instruction primarily benefits students hailing from high socioeconomic backgrounds, thereby contributing to greater educational inequality. This study also suggests pedagogical implications and areas for ongoing research. |
| Author | Hajar, Anas Karakus, Mehmet |
| Author_xml | – sequence: 1 givenname: Anas orcidid: 0000-0001-7513-9689 surname: Hajar fullname: Hajar, Anas email: anas.hajar@nu.edu.kz organization: Graduate School of Education, Nazarbayev University – sequence: 2 givenname: Mehmet orcidid: 0000-0002-3628-9809 surname: Karakus fullname: Karakus, Mehmet organization: Research Centre for Global Learning, Coventry University |
| BackLink | http://eric.ed.gov/ERICWebPortal/detail?accno=EJ1338522$$DView record in ERIC https://www.kci.go.kr/kciportal/ci/sereArticleSearch/ciSereArtiView.kci?sereArticleSearchBean.artiId=ART002856233$$DAccess content in National Research Foundation of Korea (NRF) |
| BookMark | eNp9UV1rFDEUHaSCbfUPCELAN3E0yWTy4YOwlFYrBUEq-GTIZG520u4kazJT8d83u7Mq-tCnm3DPOfeec0-qoxADVNVzgt8QjMXbTGjLWY0prbESrarZo-qYSMFrhsW3o_JulawJbsST6iTnG4x5o4g6rr6vUOe7jY8jTMlbNJrt1oc1ig7lwfTxJ4J-tmbyMaAEGUyywztk7ODhDkYIU36NNn700x5SPib0aBoAuXmaEzytHjuzyfDsUE-rrxfn12cf66vPHy7PVle1ZaKdarCuI4wzgJY4JXjX9diQ3rrWcWoxcVL1SorOtB2npgcqmWkIgGWN4b20zWn1atENyelb63U0fl_XUd8mvfpyfalLUJRgyQr4_QLezt0IvS0uktnobfKjSb_21H87wQ9F6E5LpVhLeRF4eRBI8ccMedI3cU6hGNSUi5YKRhktqBcLCkqwf9TPP5GmkS3d9eXStynmnMBpe4ixDPWbsu9uZaGX2-pyW72_rd45oP9Rf8s_SGoWUi7gsIb0d-sHWPcixbot |
| CitedBy_id | crossref_primary_10_3390_jfb15090274 crossref_primary_10_1080_01425692_2024_2397640 crossref_primary_10_1080_00220388_2023_2273798 crossref_primary_10_3389_fpsyg_2022_929045 crossref_primary_10_1007_s11159_023_10027_9 crossref_primary_10_1080_02103702_2023_2245227 crossref_primary_10_1080_01425692_2025_2474035 crossref_primary_10_3390_su15021437 crossref_primary_10_1080_19376812_2023_2256696 crossref_primary_10_1007_s35834_024_00433_w crossref_primary_10_1080_13596748_2023_2285631 crossref_primary_10_1177_17411432241242629 crossref_primary_10_1080_01434632_2023_2230962 crossref_primary_10_3224_ijree_v10i2_02 crossref_primary_10_1080_21683565_2024_2448197 crossref_primary_10_1080_09571736_2024_2361145 crossref_primary_10_1080_02103702_2023_2194792 crossref_primary_10_1080_03055698_2024_2405815 crossref_primary_10_1177_00131245241280965 crossref_primary_10_1080_09571736_2023_2213244 crossref_primary_10_3389_fpsyg_2023_1013243 crossref_primary_10_1080_14767724_2022_2143330 crossref_primary_10_1111_ejed_12646 crossref_primary_10_1080_03057925_2024_2333520 crossref_primary_10_1186_s40536_024_00228_5 crossref_primary_10_1080_00131857_2025_2468425 crossref_primary_10_1080_02634937_2023_2234420 crossref_primary_10_1080_03050068_2025_2457787 crossref_primary_10_3389_fonc_2024_1423924 crossref_primary_10_1177_20965311231167194 crossref_primary_10_1016_j_ijer_2024_102482 crossref_primary_10_1080_14767724_2024_2335658 crossref_primary_10_1016_j_ijedudev_2024_103075 |
| Cites_doi | 10.1177/0312896219877678 10.1111/ejed.12415 10.1016/j.eap.2021.04.001 10.1016/S0272-7757(03)00032-3 10.1007/s12564-009-9064-6 10.1086/706776 10.1177/0020715220987861 10.1016/j.tsc.2019.100625 10.4992/jjpsy.64.135 10.1002/j.1545-7249.2009.tb00168.x 10.1146/annurev-soc-081715-074341 10.1080/00131911.2017.1415297 10.1177/2158244020988865 10.1007/978-3-319-69119-0 10.1080/01425690600556362 10.1007/978-3-030-03982-0 10.1177/0038040712447180 10.1007/s11192-017-2300-7 10.1016/j.ijedudev.2011.01.014 10.1080/03055690701785285 10.1002/berj.3587 10.1177/0038040709356567 10.1093/wbro/lkn004 10.1177/2096531119890142 10.1007/BF03173536 10.1086/659142 10.1080/10615809208249521 10.1086/229942 10.1007/s12564-009-9065-5 10.1177/0038040711411278 10.1007/s12564-013-9276-7 10.1007/s12564-009-9057-5 10.1016/j.econedurev.2004.01.003 10.1177/2096531119840868 10.1080/0305764X.2021.2004088 10.1007/s11192-014-1460-y 10.3102/01623737023001001 10.1080/13540602.2021.2019700 10.1007/s12564-010-9070-8 10.1080/10615809208249526 10.1007/s12564-009-9056-6 10.1556/063.2021.00001 10.1177/0038040710392719 10.1080/01596306.2015.1061976 10.4324/9780203522028 10.1111/j.1746-1049.1999.tb00232.x 10.1007/BF00367916 10.1007/978-3-319-30042-9 10.1086/677907 10.1093/reseval/rvy001 10.1080/10615809208249524 10.1111/ejed.12411 10.1007/s11192-015-1765-5 10.1016/j.econedurev.2013.10.002 10.1057/978-1-137-51324-3 10.1016/j.cie.2017.08.033 10.1080/10615809208249525 10.1080/09500690701191425 10.1086/648186 10.1007/978-3-319-95915-3 10.1002/meet.14504901027 10.4324/9781003317593 10.1016/j.procs.2014.05.303 10.1086/692709 10.1080/03057925.2021.1915749 10.1108/S1479-3679(2013)0000022006 10.1080/03057920903361926 10.1177/016146810710900507 10.1353/sof.2010.0105 10.1016/j.econedurev.2012.09.008 10.1111/ejed.12410 10.1111/ejed.12413 10.1007/s12564-009-9067-3 10.14712/23363177.2020.17 10.1080/0022027940260307 10.1080/03054980801981426 10.1007/s12564-009-9058-4 |
| ContentType | Journal Article |
| Copyright | Education Research Institute, Seoul National University, Seoul, Korea 2022. Springer Nature or its licensor (e.g. a society or other partner) holds exclusive rights to this article under a publishing agreement with the author(s) or other rightsholder(s); author self-archiving of the accepted manuscript version of this article is solely governed by the terms of such publishing agreement and applicable law. Education Research Institute, Seoul National University, Seoul, Korea 2022 |
| Copyright_xml | – notice: Education Research Institute, Seoul National University, Seoul, Korea 2022. Springer Nature or its licensor (e.g. a society or other partner) holds exclusive rights to this article under a publishing agreement with the author(s) or other rightsholder(s); author self-archiving of the accepted manuscript version of this article is solely governed by the terms of such publishing agreement and applicable law. – notice: Education Research Institute, Seoul National University, Seoul, Korea 2022 |
| DBID | AAYXX CITATION 7SW BJH BNH BNI BNJ BNO ERI PET REK WWN 0-V 3V. 7XB 88B 8FK ABUWG AFKRA AHOVV ALSLI AZQEC BENPR CCPQU CJNVE DWQXO GNUQQ M0P PHGZM PHGZT PKEHL PQEDU PQEST PQQKQ PQUKI Q9U 5PM ACYCR |
| DOI | 10.1007/s12564-022-09759-4 |
| DatabaseName | CrossRef ERIC ERIC (Ovid) ERIC ERIC ERIC (Legacy Platform) ERIC( SilverPlatter ) ERIC ERIC PlusText (Legacy Platform) Education Resources Information Center (ERIC) ERIC ProQuest Social Sciences Premium Collection【Remote access available】 ProQuest Central (Corporate) ProQuest Central (purchase pre-March 2016) Education Database (Alumni Edition) ProQuest Central (Alumni) (purchase pre-March 2016) ProQuest Central (Alumni) ProQuest Central UK/Ireland Education Research Index Social Science Premium Collection ProQuest Central Essentials - QC ProQuest Central ProQuest One Education Collection ProQuest Central Korea ProQuest Central Student Education Database ProQuest Central Premium ProQuest One Academic (New) ProQuest One Academic Middle East (New) ProQuest One Education ProQuest One Academic Eastern Edition (DO NOT USE) ProQuest One Academic ProQuest One Academic UKI Edition ProQuest Central Basic PubMed Central (Full Participant titles) Korean Citation Index |
| DatabaseTitle | CrossRef ERIC ProQuest One Education Social Science Premium Collection Education Collection ProQuest Central Student ProQuest Central Basic ProQuest One Academic Middle East (New) ProQuest Education Journals ProQuest Central Essentials ProQuest One Academic Eastern Edition ProQuest Central (Alumni Edition) ProQuest One Community College ProQuest Central ProQuest Social Sciences Premium Collection ProQuest One Academic UKI Edition ProQuest Central Korea ProQuest One Academic ProQuest Central (New) ProQuest Education Journals (Alumni Edition) ProQuest Central (Alumni) ProQuest One Academic (New) |
| DatabaseTitleList | ProQuest One Education ERIC |
| Database_xml | – sequence: 1 dbid: ERI name: ERIC url: https://eric.ed.gov/ sourceTypes: Index Database – sequence: 2 dbid: BENPR name: ProQuest Central url: https://www.proquest.com/central sourceTypes: Aggregation Database |
| DeliveryMethod | fulltext_linktorsrc |
| Discipline | Education |
| EISSN | 1876-407X |
| ERIC | EJ1338522 |
| EndPage | 359 |
| ExternalDocumentID | oai_kci_go_kr_ARTI_10021084 PMC8994526 EJ1338522 10_1007_s12564_022_09759_4 |
| GrantInformation_xml | – fundername: Nazarbayev University grantid: 347/07122020 (Faculty Grant) funderid: http://dx.doi.org/10.13039/501100012632 – fundername: ; grantid: 347/07122020 (Faculty Grant) |
| GroupedDBID | -5C -5G -BR -EM -~C 0-V 06D 0R~ 0VY 1N0 203 23N 2KG 2LR 2VQ 3-Y 30V 3V. 4.4 406 408 40D 5GY 5VS 67Z 8TC 8UJ 96X AAAVM AACDK AAHNG AAIAL AAJBT AAJKR AANZL AARHV AARTL AASML AATNV AATVU AAUYE AAWCG AAYIU AAYQN AAYTO AAYZH AAZMS ABAKF ABDZT ABECU ABFTV ABIVO ABJNI ABJOX ABKCH ABMQK ABOPQ ABQBU ABSXP ABTEG ABTHY ABTKH ABTMW ABUWG ABXPI ACAOD ACDTI ACGFS ACHQT ACHSB ACHXU ACKNC ACMDZ ACMLO ACOKC ACPIV ACZOJ ADHHG ADHIR ADINQ ADKNI ADKPE ADRFC ADTPH ADURQ ADYFF ADZKW AEBTG AEFQL AEGNC AEJHL AEJRE AEMSY AEOHA AEPYU AESKC AETCA AEVLU AEXYK AFBBN AFGCZ AFKRA AFLOW AFQWF AFWTZ AFZKB AGAYW AGDGC AGJBK AGMZJ AGQEE AGQMX AGRTI AGWZB AGYKE AHAVH AHBYD AHKAY AHSBF AHYZX AIAKS AIGIU AIIXL AILAN AITGF AJBLW AJRNO AJZVZ ALMA_UNASSIGNED_HOLDINGS ALSLI AMKLP AMXSW AMYLF AMYQR ANMIH AOCGG ARALO AXYYD AYQZM AZQEC BENPR BGNMA BPHCQ CAG CCPQU CJNVE COF CSCUP DDRTE DNIVK DPUIP DWQXO EBLON EBS EIOEI EJD ESBYG FERAY FFXSO FIGPU FINBP FNLPD FRRFC FSGXE FYJPI GGCAI GGRSB GJIRD GNUQQ GQ6 GQ7 H13 HF~ HG6 HMJXF HRMNR HZ~ IKXTQ IWAJR IXC IXD I~X J-C J0Z JBSCW JZLTJ KOV LLZTM M0P M4Y MA- NPVJJ NQJWS NU0 O9- O9J P2P P9Q PQEDU PQQKQ PROAC PT4 R9I ROL RSV S1Z S27 S3B SDH SHS SHX SISQX SJYHP SNE SNPRN SNX SOHCF SOJ SPISZ SRMVM SSLCW STPWE T13 TR2 TSG U2A UG4 UOJIU UTJUX UZXMN VC2 VFIZW W48 WK8 Z45 ZMTXR ~A9 AAPKM AAYXX ABBRH ABDBE ABFSG ACSTC AEZWR AFDZB AFHIU AFOHR AHPBZ AHWEU AIXLP ATHPR AYFIA CITATION PHGZM PHGZT 7SW ABRTQ BJH BNH BNI BNJ BNO ERI PET PUEGO REK WWN 7XB 8FK AHOVV PKEHL PQEST PQUKI Q9U 5PM AAFGU AAPBV AAYFA ABFGW ABKAS ACBMV ACBRV ACBYP ACIGE ACIPQ ACTTH ACVWB ACWMK ACYCR ADMDM ADOXG AEFTE AESTI AEVTX AFNRJ AGGBP AIMYW AJDOV AKQUC |
| ID | FETCH-LOGICAL-c475t-ecfb1464ee51f976bbd0a1dcf5f62c01f89d987ba5b62ade284a31eec43a6d8c3 |
| IEDL.DBID | U2A |
| ISSN | 1598-1037 |
| IngestDate | Tue Nov 21 21:29:56 EST 2023 Thu Aug 21 13:54:23 EDT 2025 Sat Aug 23 14:51:22 EDT 2025 Tue Sep 02 19:11:19 EDT 2025 Tue Jul 01 02:14:23 EDT 2025 Thu Apr 24 22:54:25 EDT 2025 Fri Feb 21 02:43:17 EST 2025 |
| IsDoiOpenAccess | true |
| IsOpenAccess | true |
| IsPeerReviewed | false |
| IsScholarly | true |
| Issue | 2 |
| Keywords | Literature review Science mapping Bibliometric analysis Shadow education VOSviewer |
| Language | English |
| License | This article is made available via the PMC Open Access Subset for unrestricted research re-use and secondary analysis in any form or by any means with acknowledgement of the original source. These permissions are granted for the duration of the World Health Organization (WHO) declaration of COVID-19 as a global pandemic. |
| LinkModel | DirectLink |
| MergedId | FETCHMERGED-LOGICAL-c475t-ecfb1464ee51f976bbd0a1dcf5f62c01f89d987ba5b62ade284a31eec43a6d8c3 |
| Notes | ObjectType-Article-1 SourceType-Scholarly Journals-1 ObjectType-Feature-2 content type line 14 |
| ORCID | 0000-0002-3628-9809 0000-0001-7513-9689 |
| OpenAccessLink | https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/PMC8994526 |
| PQID | 2675274242 |
| PQPubID | 2034556 |
| PageCount | 19 |
| ParticipantIDs | nrf_kci_oai_kci_go_kr_ARTI_10021084 pubmedcentral_primary_oai_pubmedcentral_nih_gov_8994526 proquest_journals_2675274242 eric_primary_EJ1338522 crossref_citationtrail_10_1007_s12564_022_09759_4 crossref_primary_10_1007_s12564_022_09759_4 springer_journals_10_1007_s12564_022_09759_4 |
| ProviderPackageCode | CITATION AAYXX |
| PublicationCentury | 2000 |
| PublicationDate | 2022-06-01 |
| PublicationDateYYYYMMDD | 2022-06-01 |
| PublicationDate_xml | – month: 06 year: 2022 text: 2022-06-01 day: 01 |
| PublicationDecade | 2020 |
| PublicationPlace | Dordrecht |
| PublicationPlace_xml | – name: Dordrecht |
| PublicationTitle | Asia Pacific education review |
| PublicationTitleAbbrev | Asia Pacific Educ. Rev |
| PublicationYear | 2022 |
| Publisher | Springer Netherlands Springer Springer Nature B.V 교육연구소 |
| Publisher_xml | – name: Springer Netherlands – name: Springer – name: Springer Nature B.V – name: 교육연구소 |
| References | BrayMKobakhidzeMNSuterLEThe challenges of measuring outside-school-time educational activities: Experiences and lessons from the Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA)Comparative Education Review20206418710610.1086/706776 AuriniJDaviesSThe transformation of private tutoring: Education in a franchise formCanadian Journal of Sociology2004293419438 BrayMKwoOJokićBBrayMKwoPJokićBIntroductionResearching private supplementary tutoring: Methodological lessons from diverse cultures2016Comparative Education Research Centre32310.1007/978-3-319-30042-9 ParkHRe-evaluating education in Japan and Korea: De-mystifying stereotypes2013Routledge10.4324/9780203522028 MongeonPPaul-HusAThe journal coverage of web of science and scopus: A comparative analysisScientometrics2016106121322810.1007/s11192-015-1765-5 HajarAThe association between private tutoring and access to grammar schools: Voices of year 6 pupils and teachers in south-east EnglandBritish Educational Research Journal202010.1002/berj.3587 SriprakashAProctorHHuBVisible pedagogic work: Parenting, private tutoring and educational advantage in AustraliaDiscourse201637342644110.1080/01596306.2015.1061976 ŠťastnýVKobakhidzeMNThrowing light on shadow educationOrbis Scholae202014251210.14712/23363177.2020.17 Arabian Business. (2020). Private tutors breaking UAE coronavirus ban to face hefty. Retrieved September 2, 2021, from https://www.arabianbusiness.com/education/453498-private-tutors-breaking-uae-coronavirus-ban-to-facehefty-fine KobakhidzeMNTeachers as tutors: Shadow education market dynamics in Georgia2018Springer10.1007/978-3-319-95915-3 EntrichSShadow education and social inequalities in Japan. Evolving patterns and conceptual implications2018Springer10.1007/978-3-319-69119-0 BrayMShadow education in Europe: Growing prevalence, underlying forces, and policy implicationsECNU Review of Education20214344247510.1177/2096531119890142 Dawson, W. (2010). Private tutoring and mass schooling in East Asia: Reflections of inequality in Japan, South Korea, and Cambodia. Asia Pacific Education Review, 11(1), 14–24. FujiiYConstruction of a test influence inventory (TII)Shinrigaku Kenkyu199364213513910.4992/jjpsy.64.135 ChavarroDRàfolsITangPTo what extent is inclusion in the web of science an indicator of journal “quality”?Research Evaluation201827210611810.1093/reseval/rvy001 HarnischDLSupplemental education in Japan: Juku schooling and its implicationJournal of Curriculum Studies199426332333410.1080/0022027940260307 Dang, H. A., & Rogers, F. H. (2008). The growing phenomenon of private tutoring: Does it deepen human capital, widen inequalities, or waste resources?. The World Bank Research Observer, 23(2), 161–200. BrayMKobakhidzeMNMeasurement issues in research on shadow education: Challenges and pitfalls encountered in TIMSS and PISAComparative Education Review201458459062010.1086/677907 StevensonDLBakerDPShadow education and allocation in formal schooling: Transition to university in JapanAmerican Journal of Sociology19929761639165710.1086/229942 ByunSYSchoferEKimKKRevisiting the role of cultural capital in East Asian educational systems: The case of South KoreaSociology of Education201285321923910.1177/0038040712447180 Biswal, B. P. (1999). Private tutoring and public corruption: A cost-effective education system for developing countries. The Developing Economies, 37(2), 222–240. Mori, I., & Baker, D. (2010). The origin of universal shadow education: What the supplemental education phenomenon tells us about the postmodern institution of education. Asia Pacific Education Review, 11(1), 36–48. VenturaAGomesAAuriniJDaviesSDierkesJSupplementary education in Brazil: Diversity and paradoxesOut of the shadows: The global intensification of supplementary education2013Bingley12915110.1108/S1479-3679(2013)0000022006 MalikMAShadow education: Evolution, flaws and further development of the termSocial Sciences and Education Research Review201741629 Lynch, K., & Moran, M. (2006). Markets, schools and the convertibility of economic capital: the complex dynamics of class choice. British Journal of Sociology of Education, 27(02), 221–235. Baker, D. P., Akiba, M., LeTendre, G. K., & Wiseman, A. W. (2001). Worldwide shadow education: Outside-school learning, institutional quality of schooling, and cross-national mathematics achievement. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 23(1), 1–17. LeydesdorffLFeltU“Books” and “book chapters” in the book citation index (BKCI) and science citation index (SCI, SoSCI, A&HCI)Proceedings of the American Society for Information Science and Technology20124911710.1002/meet.14504901027 BrayMThe challenge of shadow education: Private tutoring and its implications for policy makers in the European Union2011European Commission Bray, M. & Hajar, A. (2022). Shadow education in the Middle East: private supplementary tutoring and its policy implications. London: Routledge. Hernández-TorranoDIbrayevaLCreativity and education: A bibliometric mapping of the research literature (1975–2019)Thinking Skills and Creativity20203510062510.1016/j.tsc.2019.100625 BakerDPAn inevitable phenomenon: Reflections on the origins and future of worldwide shadow educationEuropean Journal of Education202055331131510.1111/ejed.12410 ZhangWBrayMPrivate supplementary tutoring: Contexts, patterns, and developments [Special issue]ECNU Review of Education201921194 ZhangWRegulating private tutoring in China: Uniform policies, diverse responsesECNU Review of Education201921254310.1177/2096531119840868 Psacharopoulos, G., & Papakonstantinou, G. (2005). The real university cost in a “free” higher education country. Economics of education review, 24(1), 103–108. Kim, S., & Lee, J. H. (2010). Private tutoring and demand for education in South Korea. Economic Development and Cultural Change, 58(2), 259–296. BrayMGeographies of shadow education: Patterns and forces in the spatial distributions of private supplementary tutoringCompare202110.1080/03057925.2021.1915749 KobakhidzeNSuterLThe global diversity of shadow educationEuropean Journal of Education202055331632110.1111/ejed.12411 LinnenlueckeMKMarroneMSinghAKConducting systematic literature reviews and bibliometric analysesAustralian Journal of Management202045217519410.1177/0312896219877678 EckNJWaltmanLVOSviewer manual2019Universitat Leiden KimJHParkDThe determinants of demand for private tutoring in South KoreaAsia Pacific Education Review201011341142110.1007/s12564-009-9067-3 BrayMLeeCJEditorial [special issue]Asia Pacific Education Review.2010111210.1007/s12564-010-9070-8 SilovaIBūdienėVBrayMEducation in a hidden marketplace: Monitoring of private tutoring2006Open Society Institute ZhangYDoes private tutoring improve students’ National College entrance exam performance?—A case study from Jinan, ChinaEconomics of Education Review20133212810.1016/j.econedurev.2012.09.008 BrayMKwokPDemand for private supplementary tutoring: Conceptual considerations, and socio-economic patterns in Hong KongEconomics of Education Review200322661162010.1016/S0272-7757(03)00032-3 VenturaAJangSPrivate tutoring through the internet: Globalization and offshoringAsia Pacific Education Review2010111596810.1007/s12564-009-9065-5 BuchmannCCondronDJRoscignoVJShadow education, American style: Test preparation, the SAT and college enrollmentSocial Forces201089243546110.1353/sof.2010.0105 MarimuthuTSinghJSAhmadKLimHKMukherjeeHOsmanSJamaluddinWExtra-school instruction, social equity and education quality [in Malaysia]1991International Development Research Centre UNESCO GEM report (2021). Non-state actors in education: Who chooses? Who loses? Global education monitoring report, 2021/2: non-state actors in education: who chooses? who loses?—UNESCO Digital Library BrayMKobakhidzeMNKwoOShadow education in Myanmar: Private supplementary tutoring and its policy implications2020Comparative Education Research Centre, The University of Hong Kong, UNESCO MandikianaBWChoice and expenditure: A double hurdle model of private tutoring in QatarEconomic Analysis and Policy20217111510.1016/j.eap.2021.04.001 EckNJWaltmanLGlänzelWCitation-based clustering of publications using CitNetExplorer and VOSviewerScientometrics201711121053107010.1007/s11192-017-2300-7 BrayMShadow education in Africa: Private supplementary tutoring and its policy implications2021Comparative Education Research Centre, The University of Hong Kong, UNESCO BrayMThe shadow education system: Private tutoring and its implications for planners. Fundamentals of educational planning1999ParisUNESCO International Institute for Educational Planning (IIEP)61 Silova, I. (2010). Private tutoring in Eastern Europe and Central Asia: Policy choices and implications. Compare, 40(3), 327–344. SmythEBuying your way into college? Private tuition and the transition to higher education in IrelandOxford Review of Education200935112210.1080/03054980801981426 TsaiCCKuoPCCram school students’ conceptions of learning and learning science in TaiwanInternational Journal of Science Education200830335337510.1080/09500690701191425 CancinoCMerigoJMCoronadoFDessoukyYDessoukyMForty years of computers & industrial engineering: A bibliometric analysisComputers & Industrial Engineering201711361462910.1016/j.cie.2017.08.033 BrayMKwoORegulating private tutoring for public good: Policy options for supplementary education in Asia2014Comparative Education Research Centre, The University of Hong Kong, UNESCO CoboMJMartínezMAGutiérrez-SalcedoMHerreraMHerrera-ViedmaEIdentifying citation classics in fuzzy decision making field using the concept of H-classicsProcedia Computer Science20143156757610.1016/j.procs.2014.05.303 O'NeilHFAbediJJapanese children's trait and state worry and emotionality in a high-stakes testing environmentAnxiety, Stress, and Coping19925325326710.1080/10615809208249526 BrayMLykinsCShadow education: Private supplementary tutoring and its implications for policy makers in Asia2012Asian Development Bank, Comparative Education Research Centre, The University of Hong Kong NathSRPrivate supplementary tut A Ventura (9759_CR83) 2010; 11 C Mischo (9759_CR66) 2002; 17 9759_CR101 HL Hemachandra (9759_CR46) 1982; 5 M Bray (9759_CR21) 2012 9759_CR102 YC Kim (9759_CR52) 2016 9759_CR100 9759_CR105 9759_CR106 9759_CR103 NJ Eck (9759_CR32) 2019 9759_CR104 9759_CR109 9759_CR107 CC Tsai (9759_CR80) 2008; 30 9759_CR108 M Bray (9759_CR7) 2010; 11 W Zhang (9759_CR90) 2020; 55 9759_CR38 L Leydesdorff (9759_CR59) 2012; 49 Y Fujii (9759_CR37) 1993; 64 MK Linnenluecke (9759_CR60) 2020; 45 T Marimuthu (9759_CR64) 1991 M Bray (9759_CR19) 2003; 22 M Bray (9759_CR11) 2021 S Zhan (9759_CR87) 2013; 14 (9759_CR74) 2006 9759_CR28 JG Gordon Győri (9759_CR39) 2020; 55 A Hajar (9759_CR41) 2021; 11 Y Yamamoto (9759_CR84) 2010; 83 C Buchmann (9759_CR24) 2010; 89 M Bray (9759_CR6) 2009 J Liu (9759_CR61) 2012; 32 W Zhang (9759_CR88) 2019; 2 C Cancino (9759_CR26) 2017; 113 M Bray (9759_CR10) 2021 NJ Eck (9759_CR33) 2017; 111 M Bray (9759_CR17) 2014 A Sriprakash (9759_CR77) 2016; 37 M Bray (9759_CR5) 2003 9759_CR81 MV DeVault (9759_CR31) 1977; 58 M Bray (9759_CR23) 2014; 38 SR Entrich (9759_CR34) 2018 MO Hamid (9759_CR43) 2009; 43 M Karakus (9759_CR50) 2021 J Lee (9759_CR57) 2007; 109 P Mongeon (9759_CR67) 2016; 106 Y Zhang (9759_CR91) 2013; 32 M Bray (9759_CR15) 2020 MGA Hussein (9759_CR48) 1987; 18 JH Kim (9759_CR51) 2010; 11 KWH Yung (9759_CR85) 2017 L Ivanović (9759_CR49) 2019; 71 9759_CR1 J Aurini (9759_CR2) 2004; 29 DP Baker (9759_CR3) 2020; 55 M Bray (9759_CR4) 1999 DL Harnisch (9759_CR44) 1994; 26 M Bray (9759_CR18) 2016 A Ventura (9759_CR82) 2013 KWH Yung (9759_CR86) 2020; 41 A Hajar (9759_CR40) 2020 HF O'Neil (9759_CR69) 1992; 5 MN Kobakhidze (9759_CR54) 2018 S Lee (9759_CR58) 2011; 84 (9759_CR22) 2013 M Bray (9759_CR9) 2017; 61 D Hernández-Torrano (9759_CR47) 2020; 35 M Bray (9759_CR14) 2014; 58 HF O'Neil (9759_CR71) 1992; 5 H Park (9759_CR73) 2011; 84 SR Nath (9759_CR68) 2008; 34 M Bray (9759_CR16) 2020; 64 DE Southgate (9759_CR76) 2009 E Smyth (9759_CR75) 2009; 35 S Entrich (9759_CR35) 2018 HF O'Neil (9759_CR70) 1992; 5 A Hajar (9759_CR42) 2021 JN Hawkins (9759_CR45) 1992; 5 SY Byun (9759_CR25) 2012; 85 SR Entrich (9759_CR36) 2021; 61 M Bray (9759_CR13) 2021; 4 CJ Lee (9759_CR56) 2010; 11 V Šťastný (9759_CR78) 2020; 14 DL Stevenson (9759_CR79) 1992; 97 D Chavarro (9759_CR27) 2018; 27 MJ Cobo (9759_CR29) 2014; 31 MA Martínez (9759_CR65) 2015; 102 J Delors (9759_CR30) 1996 BW Mandikiana (9759_CR63) 2021; 71 W Zhang (9759_CR89) 2019; 2 9759_CR110 9759_CR111 N Kobakhidze (9759_CR55) 2020; 55 YC Kim (9759_CR53) 2019 MA Malik (9759_CR62) 2017; 4 H Park (9759_CR72) 2013 M Bray (9759_CR8) 2011 M Bray (9759_CR12) 2021 M Bray (9759_CR20) 2010; 11 |
| References_xml | – reference: YamamotoYBrintonMCCultural capital in East Asian educational systems: The case of JapanSociology of Education2010831678310.1177/0038040709356567 – reference: AuriniJDaviesSThe transformation of private tutoring: Education in a franchise formCanadian Journal of Sociology2004293419438 – reference: KobakhidzeNSuterLThe global diversity of shadow educationEuropean Journal of Education202055331632110.1111/ejed.12411 – reference: KarakusMUsakMErsozluAEmotions in learning, teaching, and leadership: A bibliometric review of Asian literature (1990–2018)SAGE Open202110.1177/2158244020988865 – reference: BrayMKobakhidzeMNKwoOShadow education in Myanmar: Private supplementary tutoring and its policy implications2020Comparative Education Research Centre, The University of Hong Kong, UNESCO – reference: FujiiYConstruction of a test influence inventory (TII)Shinrigaku Kenkyu199364213513910.4992/jjpsy.64.135 – reference: BrayMShadow education in Africa: Private supplementary tutoring and its policy implications2021Comparative Education Research Centre, The University of Hong Kong, UNESCO – reference: O'NeilHFBakerELMatsuuraSReliability and validity of Japanese children's trait and state worry and emotionality scalesAnxiety, Stress, and Coping19925322523910.1080/10615809208249524 – reference: ZhangYDoes private tutoring improve students’ National College entrance exam performance?—A case study from Jinan, ChinaEconomics of Education Review20133212810.1016/j.econedurev.2012.09.008 – reference: HemachandraHLThe growing phenomena of tuition classes: The perceived reasons and some latent social factorsSri Lanka Journal of Social Sciences1982523969 – reference: MartínezMAHerreraMContrerasERuizAHerrera-ViedmaECharacterizing highly cited papers in social work through H-classicsScientometrics201510221713172910.1007/s11192-014-1460-y – reference: HajarASagintayevaAIzekenovaZChild participatory research methods: Exploring grade 6 pupils’ experiences of private tutoring in KazakhstanCambridge Journal of Education202110.1080/0305764X.2021.2004088 – reference: IvanovićLHoYSHighly cited articles in the education and educational research category in the social science citation index: A bibliometric analysisEducational Review201971327728610.1080/00131911.2017.1415297 – reference: HajarAThe association between private tutoring and access to grammar schools: Voices of year 6 pupils and teachers in south-east EnglandBritish Educational Research Journal202010.1002/berj.3587 – reference: Bray, M. & Hajar, A. (2022). Shadow education in the Middle East: private supplementary tutoring and its policy implications. London: Routledge. – reference: EckNJWaltmanLVOSviewer manual2019Universitat Leiden – reference: StevensonDLBakerDPShadow education and allocation in formal schooling: Transition to university in JapanAmerican Journal of Sociology19929761639165710.1086/229942 – reference: DelorsJLearning: The treasure within. Report to UNESCO of the International Commission on Education for the Twenty-First Century1996UNESCO – reference: Park, H., Buchmann, C., Choi, J., & Merry, J. J. (2016). Learning beyond the school walls: Trends and implications. Annual Review of Sociology, 42, 231–252. – reference: BrayMGeographies of shadow education: Patterns and forces in the spatial distributions of private supplementary tutoringCompare202110.1080/03057925.2021.1915749 – reference: LeydesdorffLFeltU“Books” and “book chapters” in the book citation index (BKCI) and science citation index (SCI, SoSCI, A&HCI)Proceedings of the American Society for Information Science and Technology20124911710.1002/meet.14504901027 – reference: ParkHRe-evaluating education in Japan and Korea: De-mystifying stereotypes2013Routledge10.4324/9780203522028 – reference: ZhangWBrayMPrivate supplementary tutoring: Contexts, patterns, and developments [Special issue]ECNU Review of Education201921194 – reference: MarimuthuTSinghJSAhmadKLimHKMukherjeeHOsmanSJamaluddinWExtra-school instruction, social equity and education quality [in Malaysia]1991International Development Research Centre – reference: BrayMConfronting the shadow education system: What government policies for what private tutoring?2009UNESCO International Institute for Educational Planning (IIEP)132 – reference: BrayMSchooling and its supplements: Changing global patterns and implications for comparative educationComparative Education Review201761346949110.1086/692709 – reference: O'NeilHFAbediJJapanese children's trait and state worry and emotionality in a high-stakes testing environmentAnxiety, Stress, and Coping19925325326710.1080/10615809208249526 – reference: MalikMAShadow education: Evolution, flaws and further development of the termSocial Sciences and Education Research Review201741629 – reference: MongeonPPaul-HusAThe journal coverage of web of science and scopus: A comparative analysisScientometrics2016106121322810.1007/s11192-015-1765-5 – reference: KimJHParkDThe determinants of demand for private tutoring in South KoreaAsia Pacific Education Review201011341142110.1007/s12564-009-9067-3 – reference: ZhanSBrayMWangDLykinsCKwoOThe effectiveness of private tutoring: Students’ perceptions in comparison with mainstream schooling in Hong KongAsia Pacific Education Review201314449550910.1007/s12564-013-9276-7 – reference: EntrichSRWorldwide shadow education and social inequality: Explaining differences in the socioeconomic gap in access to shadow education across 63 societiesInternational Journal of Comparative Sociology20216144110.1177/0020715220987861 – reference: Hernández-TorranoDIbrayevaLCreativity and education: A bibliometric mapping of the research literature (1975–2019)Thinking Skills and Creativity20203510062510.1016/j.tsc.2019.100625 – reference: KobakhidzeMNTeachers as tutors: Shadow education market dynamics in Georgia2018Springer10.1007/978-3-319-95915-3 – reference: SouthgateDEDeterminants of shadow education: A cross-national analysis2009Ohio State University – reference: SmythEBuying your way into college? Private tuition and the transition to higher education in IrelandOxford Review of Education200935112210.1080/03054980801981426 – reference: HusseinMGAPrivate tutoring: A hidden educational problemEducational Studies in Mathematics1987181919610.1007/BF00367916 – reference: CoboMJMartínezMAGutiérrez-SalcedoMHerreraMHerrera-ViedmaEIdentifying citation classics in fuzzy decision making field using the concept of H-classicsProcedia Computer Science20143156757610.1016/j.procs.2014.05.303 – reference: UNESCO GEM report (2021). Non-state actors in education: Who chooses? Who loses? Global education monitoring report, 2021/2: non-state actors in education: who chooses? who loses?—UNESCO Digital Library – reference: Dawson, W. (2010). Private tutoring and mass schooling in East Asia: Reflections of inequality in Japan, South Korea, and Cambodia. Asia Pacific Education Review, 11(1), 14–24. – reference: Kuan, P. Y. (2011). Effects of cram schooling on mathematics performance: Evidence from junior high students in Taiwan. Comparative education review, 55(3), 342–368. – reference: BrayMKwokPDemand for private supplementary tutoring: Conceptual considerations, and socio-economic patterns in Hong KongEconomics of Education Review200322661162010.1016/S0272-7757(03)00032-3 – reference: Biswal, B. P. (1999). Private tutoring and public corruption: A cost-effective education system for developing countries. The Developing Economies, 37(2), 222–240. – reference: YungKWHBrayMTseTKCLeeMShadow education: Features, expansion and implicationsMaking sense of education in post-handover Hong Kong: Achievements and challenges2017Routledge95111 – reference: LeeSShouseRCThe impact of prestige orientation on shadow education in South KoreaSociology of Education201184321222410.1177/0038040711411278 – reference: HarnischDLSupplemental education in Japan: Juku schooling and its implicationJournal of Curriculum Studies199426332333410.1080/0022027940260307 – reference: ParkHByunSYKimKKParental involvement and students’ cognitive outcomes in Korea: Focusing on private tutoringSociology of Education201184132210.1177/0038040710392719 – reference: BrayMThe challenge of shadow education: Private tutoring and its implications for policy makers in the European Union2011European Commission – reference: BrayMZhanSLykinsCWangDKwoODifferentiated demand for private supplementary tutoring: Patterns and implications in Hong Kong secondary educationEconomics of Education Review201438243710.1016/j.econedurev.2013.10.002 – reference: Mori, I., & Baker, D. (2010). The origin of universal shadow education: What the supplemental education phenomenon tells us about the postmodern institution of education. Asia Pacific Education Review, 11(1), 36–48. – reference: Arabian Business. (2020). Private tutors breaking UAE coronavirus ban to face hefty. Retrieved September 2, 2021, from https://www.arabianbusiness.com/education/453498-private-tutors-breaking-uae-coronavirus-ban-to-facehefty-fine – reference: KimYCShadow education and the curriculum and culture of schooling in South Korea2016Palgrave Macmillan10.1057/978-1-137-51324-3 – reference: BrayMAdverse effects of supplementary private tutoring: Dimensions, implications, and government responses. Series: “Ethics and Corruption in Education”2003UNESCO International Institute for Educational Planning – reference: TsaiCCKuoPCCram school students’ conceptions of learning and learning science in TaiwanInternational Journal of Science Education200830335337510.1080/09500690701191425 – reference: NathSRPrivate supplementary tutoring among primary students in BangladeshEducational Studies2008341557210.1080/03055690701785285 – reference: Dang, H. A., & Rogers, F. H. (2008). The growing phenomenon of private tutoring: Does it deepen human capital, widen inequalities, or waste resources?. The World Bank Research Observer, 23(2), 161–200. – reference: SilovaIBūdienėVBrayMEducation in a hidden marketplace: Monitoring of private tutoring2006Open Society Institute – reference: DeVaultMVKatoKGakushu-juku: Japan's second system of educationPhi Delta Kappan19775810735736 – reference: EntrichSShadow education and social inequalities in Japan. Evolving patterns and conceptual implications2018Springer10.1007/978-3-319-69119-0 – reference: BrayMThe shadow education system: Private tutoring and its implications for planners. Fundamentals of educational planning1999ParisUNESCO International Institute for Educational Planning (IIEP)61 – reference: BrayMLykinsCShadow education: Private supplementary tutoring and its implications for policy makers in Asia2012Asian Development Bank, Comparative Education Research Centre, The University of Hong Kong – reference: LinnenlueckeMKMarroneMSinghAKConducting systematic literature reviews and bibliometric analysesAustralian Journal of Management202045217519410.1177/0312896219877678 – reference: VenturaAGomesAAuriniJDaviesSDierkesJSupplementary education in Brazil: Diversity and paradoxesOut of the shadows: The global intensification of supplementary education2013Bingley12915110.1108/S1479-3679(2013)0000022006 – reference: Kim, S., & Lee, J. H. (2010). Private tutoring and demand for education in South Korea. Economic Development and Cultural Change, 58(2), 259–296. – reference: MischoCHaagLExpansion and effectiveness of private tutoringEuropean Journal of Psychology of Education200217326327310.1007/BF03173536 – reference: ZhangWBrayMComparative research on shadow education: Achievements, challenges, and the agenda aheadEuropean Journal of Education202055332234110.1111/ejed.12413 – reference: BrayMShadow education in Europe: Growing prevalence, underlying forces, and policy implicationsECNU Review of Education20214344247510.1177/2096531119890142 – reference: ByunSYSchoferEKimKKRevisiting the role of cultural capital in East Asian educational systems: The case of South KoreaSociology of Education201285321923910.1177/0038040712447180 – reference: O'NeilHFFukumuraTRelationship of worry and emotionality to test performance in a Juku environmentAnxiety, Stress, and Coping19925324125110.1080/10615809208249525 – reference: BrayMLeeCJEditorial [special issue]Asia Pacific Education Review.2010111210.1007/s12564-010-9070-8 – reference: BrayMKwoOJokićBBrayMKwoPJokićBIntroductionResearching private supplementary tutoring: Methodological lessons from diverse cultures2016Comparative Education Research Centre32310.1007/978-3-319-30042-9 – reference: BrayMKwoORegulating private tutoring for public good: Policy options for supplementary education in Asia2014Comparative Education Research Centre, The University of Hong Kong, UNESCO – reference: ChavarroDRàfolsITangPTo what extent is inclusion in the web of science an indicator of journal “quality”?Research Evaluation201827210611810.1093/reseval/rvy001 – reference: George, C. (1992). Time to come out of the shadows. Straits Times, April 4, p. 28 – reference: LiuJDoes cram schooling matter? Who goes to cram schools? Evidence from TaiwanInternational Journal of Educational Development2012321465210.1016/j.ijedudev.2011.01.014 – reference: MandikianaBWChoice and expenditure: A double hurdle model of private tutoring in QatarEconomic Analysis and Policy20217111510.1016/j.eap.2021.04.001 – reference: Psacharopoulos, G., & Papakonstantinou, G. (2005). The real university cost in a “free” higher education country. Economics of education review, 24(1), 103–108. – reference: KimYCJungJShadow education as worldwide curriculum studies2019Palgrave Macmillan10.1007/978-3-030-03982-0 – reference: SriprakashAProctorHHuBVisible pedagogic work: Parenting, private tutoring and educational advantage in AustraliaDiscourse201637342644110.1080/01596306.2015.1061976 – reference: BrayMKobakhidzeMNMeasurement issues in research on shadow education: Challenges and pitfalls encountered in TIMSS and PISAComparative Education Review201458459062010.1086/677907 – reference: BrayMTeachers as tutors, and tutors as teachers: Blurring professional boundaries in changing erasTeachers and Teaching202110.1080/13540602.2021.2019700 – reference: Clarivate Analytics (2022). Web of science: summary of coverage. Retrieved January 2, 2022, from https://clarivate.libguides.com/webofscienceplatform/coverage – reference: HajarAAbenovaSThe role of private tutoring in admission to higher education: Evidence from a highly selective university in KazakhstanHungarian Education Research Journal202111211910.1556/063.2021.00001 – reference: HamidMOSussexRKhanAPrivate tutoring in English for secondary school students in BangladeshTESOL Quarterly200943228130810.1002/j.1545-7249.2009.tb00168.x – reference: Gordon GyőriJGShadow education—opportunity for development [special issue]European Journal of Education202055330510.1111/ejed.12415 – reference: LeeJTwo worlds of private tutoring: The prevalence and causes of after-school mathematics tutoring in Korea and the United StatesTeachers College Record200710951207123410.1177/016146810710900507 – reference: ŠťastnýVKobakhidzeMNThrowing light on shadow educationOrbis Scholae202014251210.14712/23363177.2020.17 – reference: CancinoCMerigoJMCoronadoFDessoukyYDessoukyMForty years of computers & industrial engineering: A bibliometric analysisComputers & Industrial Engineering201711361462910.1016/j.cie.2017.08.033 – reference: LeeCJLeeHJangHMThe history of policy responses to shadow education in South Korea: Implications for the next cycle of policy responsesAsia Pacific Education Review20101119710810.1007/s12564-009-9064-6 – reference: VenturaAJangSPrivate tutoring through the internet: Globalization and offshoringAsia Pacific Education Review2010111596810.1007/s12564-009-9065-5 – reference: BakerDPAn inevitable phenomenon: Reflections on the origins and future of worldwide shadow educationEuropean Journal of Education202055331131510.1111/ejed.12410 – reference: YungKWHYuanR‘The most popular star-tutor of English’: Discursive construction of tutor identities in shadow educationDiscourse2020411153168 – reference: BrayMKobakhidzeMNSuterLEThe challenges of measuring outside-school-time educational activities: Experiences and lessons from the Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA)Comparative Education Review20206418710610.1086/706776 – reference: BuchmannCCondronDJRoscignoVJShadow education, American style: Test preparation, the SAT and college enrollmentSocial Forces201089243546110.1353/sof.2010.0105 – reference: HawkinsJNTanakaYJapanese education: A context for test anxietyAnxiety, Stress, and Coping19925319520310.1080/10615809208249521 – reference: Lynch, K., & Moran, M. (2006). Markets, schools and the convertibility of economic capital: the complex dynamics of class choice. British Journal of Sociology of Education, 27(02), 221–235. – reference: ZhangWRegulating private tutoring in China: Uniform policies, diverse responsesECNU Review of Education201921254310.1177/2096531119840868 – reference: Baker, D. P., Akiba, M., LeTendre, G. K., & Wiseman, A. W. (2001). Worldwide shadow education: Outside-school learning, institutional quality of schooling, and cross-national mathematics achievement. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 23(1), 1–17. – reference: EckNJWaltmanLGlänzelWCitation-based clustering of publications using CitNetExplorer and VOSviewerScientometrics201711121053107010.1007/s11192-017-2300-7 – reference: EntrichSRShadow education and social inequalities in Japan: Evolving patterns and conceptual implications2018Springer10.1007/978-3-319-69119-0 – reference: BrayMMazawiAESultanaRGPrivate tutoring across the Mediterranean: Power dynamics and implications for learning and equity2013Sense Publishers – reference: BrayMResearching shadow education: Methodological challenges and directionsAsia Pacific Education Review201011131310.1007/s12564-009-9056-6 – reference: Silova, I. (2010). Private tutoring in Eastern Europe and Central Asia: Policy choices and implications. Compare, 40(3), 327–344. – volume: 45 start-page: 175 issue: 2 year: 2020 ident: 9759_CR60 publication-title: Australian Journal of Management doi: 10.1177/0312896219877678 – volume: 55 start-page: 305 issue: 3 year: 2020 ident: 9759_CR39 publication-title: European Journal of Education doi: 10.1111/ejed.12415 – volume: 5 start-page: 39 issue: 2 year: 1982 ident: 9759_CR46 publication-title: Sri Lanka Journal of Social Sciences – volume: 71 start-page: 1 year: 2021 ident: 9759_CR63 publication-title: Economic Analysis and Policy doi: 10.1016/j.eap.2021.04.001 – volume: 22 start-page: 611 issue: 6 year: 2003 ident: 9759_CR19 publication-title: Economics of Education Review doi: 10.1016/S0272-7757(03)00032-3 – volume: 11 start-page: 97 issue: 1 year: 2010 ident: 9759_CR56 publication-title: Asia Pacific Education Review doi: 10.1007/s12564-009-9064-6 – volume: 64 start-page: 87 issue: 1 year: 2020 ident: 9759_CR16 publication-title: Comparative Education Review doi: 10.1086/706776 – volume: 61 start-page: 441 year: 2021 ident: 9759_CR36 publication-title: International Journal of Comparative Sociology doi: 10.1177/0020715220987861 – start-page: 95 volume-title: Making sense of education in post-handover Hong Kong: Achievements and challenges year: 2017 ident: 9759_CR85 – volume: 35 start-page: 100625 year: 2020 ident: 9759_CR47 publication-title: Thinking Skills and Creativity doi: 10.1016/j.tsc.2019.100625 – volume-title: VOSviewer manual year: 2019 ident: 9759_CR32 – volume-title: Adverse effects of supplementary private tutoring: Dimensions, implications, and government responses. Series: “Ethics and Corruption in Education” year: 2003 ident: 9759_CR5 – volume: 64 start-page: 135 issue: 2 year: 1993 ident: 9759_CR37 publication-title: Shinrigaku Kenkyu doi: 10.4992/jjpsy.64.135 – volume-title: Shadow education in Africa: Private supplementary tutoring and its policy implications year: 2021 ident: 9759_CR10 – volume: 43 start-page: 281 issue: 2 year: 2009 ident: 9759_CR43 publication-title: TESOL Quarterly doi: 10.1002/j.1545-7249.2009.tb00168.x – ident: 9759_CR108 doi: 10.1146/annurev-soc-081715-074341 – volume: 2 start-page: 1 issue: 1 year: 2019 ident: 9759_CR89 publication-title: ECNU Review of Education – volume: 71 start-page: 277 issue: 3 year: 2019 ident: 9759_CR49 publication-title: Educational Review doi: 10.1080/00131911.2017.1415297 – ident: 9759_CR81 – year: 2021 ident: 9759_CR50 publication-title: SAGE Open doi: 10.1177/2158244020988865 – volume-title: Shadow education and social inequalities in Japan. Evolving patterns and conceptual implications year: 2018 ident: 9759_CR35 doi: 10.1007/978-3-319-69119-0 – ident: 9759_CR106 doi: 10.1080/01425690600556362 – volume-title: Shadow education as worldwide curriculum studies year: 2019 ident: 9759_CR53 doi: 10.1007/978-3-030-03982-0 – volume: 85 start-page: 219 issue: 3 year: 2012 ident: 9759_CR25 publication-title: Sociology of Education doi: 10.1177/0038040712447180 – volume: 111 start-page: 1053 issue: 2 year: 2017 ident: 9759_CR33 publication-title: Scientometrics doi: 10.1007/s11192-017-2300-7 – volume: 32 start-page: 46 issue: 1 year: 2012 ident: 9759_CR61 publication-title: International Journal of Educational Development doi: 10.1016/j.ijedudev.2011.01.014 – volume-title: Learning: The treasure within. Report to UNESCO of the International Commission on Education for the Twenty-First Century year: 1996 ident: 9759_CR30 – volume-title: Extra-school instruction, social equity and education quality [in Malaysia] year: 1991 ident: 9759_CR64 – volume-title: Shadow education in Myanmar: Private supplementary tutoring and its policy implications year: 2020 ident: 9759_CR15 – volume: 34 start-page: 55 issue: 1 year: 2008 ident: 9759_CR68 publication-title: Educational Studies doi: 10.1080/03055690701785285 – year: 2020 ident: 9759_CR40 publication-title: British Educational Research Journal doi: 10.1002/berj.3587 – ident: 9759_CR28 – volume: 83 start-page: 67 issue: 1 year: 2010 ident: 9759_CR84 publication-title: Sociology of Education doi: 10.1177/0038040709356567 – ident: 9759_CR102 doi: 10.1093/wbro/lkn004 – volume: 4 start-page: 442 issue: 3 year: 2021 ident: 9759_CR13 publication-title: ECNU Review of Education doi: 10.1177/2096531119890142 – volume: 17 start-page: 263 issue: 3 year: 2002 ident: 9759_CR66 publication-title: European Journal of Psychology of Education doi: 10.1007/BF03173536 – ident: 9759_CR105 doi: 10.1086/659142 – start-page: 61 volume-title: The shadow education system: Private tutoring and its implications for planners. Fundamentals of educational planning year: 1999 ident: 9759_CR4 – volume: 5 start-page: 195 issue: 3 year: 1992 ident: 9759_CR45 publication-title: Anxiety, Stress, and Coping doi: 10.1080/10615809208249521 – volume: 97 start-page: 1639 issue: 6 year: 1992 ident: 9759_CR79 publication-title: American Journal of Sociology doi: 10.1086/229942 – volume: 11 start-page: 59 issue: 1 year: 2010 ident: 9759_CR83 publication-title: Asia Pacific Education Review doi: 10.1007/s12564-009-9065-5 – volume: 84 start-page: 212 issue: 3 year: 2011 ident: 9759_CR58 publication-title: Sociology of Education doi: 10.1177/0038040711411278 – volume-title: Determinants of shadow education: A cross-national analysis year: 2009 ident: 9759_CR76 – volume: 14 start-page: 495 issue: 4 year: 2013 ident: 9759_CR87 publication-title: Asia Pacific Education Review doi: 10.1007/s12564-013-9276-7 – volume: 29 start-page: 419 issue: 3 year: 2004 ident: 9759_CR2 publication-title: Canadian Journal of Sociology – volume-title: Regulating private tutoring for public good: Policy options for supplementary education in Asia year: 2014 ident: 9759_CR17 – ident: 9759_CR107 doi: 10.1007/s12564-009-9057-5 – ident: 9759_CR109 doi: 10.1016/j.econedurev.2004.01.003 – volume: 58 start-page: 735 issue: 10 year: 1977 ident: 9759_CR31 publication-title: Phi Delta Kappan – volume: 2 start-page: 25 issue: 1 year: 2019 ident: 9759_CR88 publication-title: ECNU Review of Education doi: 10.1177/2096531119840868 – year: 2021 ident: 9759_CR42 publication-title: Cambridge Journal of Education doi: 10.1080/0305764X.2021.2004088 – volume: 102 start-page: 1713 issue: 2 year: 2015 ident: 9759_CR65 publication-title: Scientometrics doi: 10.1007/s11192-014-1460-y – ident: 9759_CR100 doi: 10.3102/01623737023001001 – year: 2021 ident: 9759_CR12 publication-title: Teachers and Teaching doi: 10.1080/13540602.2021.2019700 – volume: 11 start-page: 1 year: 2010 ident: 9759_CR20 publication-title: Asia Pacific Education Review. doi: 10.1007/s12564-010-9070-8 – volume: 5 start-page: 253 issue: 3 year: 1992 ident: 9759_CR69 publication-title: Anxiety, Stress, and Coping doi: 10.1080/10615809208249526 – volume: 11 start-page: 3 issue: 1 year: 2010 ident: 9759_CR7 publication-title: Asia Pacific Education Review doi: 10.1007/s12564-009-9056-6 – volume: 11 start-page: 1 issue: 2 year: 2021 ident: 9759_CR41 publication-title: Hungarian Education Research Journal doi: 10.1556/063.2021.00001 – volume: 84 start-page: 3 issue: 1 year: 2011 ident: 9759_CR73 publication-title: Sociology of Education doi: 10.1177/0038040710392719 – volume: 37 start-page: 426 issue: 3 year: 2016 ident: 9759_CR77 publication-title: Discourse doi: 10.1080/01596306.2015.1061976 – volume-title: Re-evaluating education in Japan and Korea: De-mystifying stereotypes year: 2013 ident: 9759_CR72 doi: 10.4324/9780203522028 – ident: 9759_CR101 doi: 10.1111/j.1746-1049.1999.tb00232.x – volume: 41 start-page: 153 issue: 1 year: 2020 ident: 9759_CR86 publication-title: Discourse – volume-title: The challenge of shadow education: Private tutoring and its implications for policy makers in the European Union year: 2011 ident: 9759_CR8 – volume: 18 start-page: 91 issue: 1 year: 1987 ident: 9759_CR48 publication-title: Educational Studies in Mathematics doi: 10.1007/BF00367916 – start-page: 3 volume-title: Researching private supplementary tutoring: Methodological lessons from diverse cultures year: 2016 ident: 9759_CR18 doi: 10.1007/978-3-319-30042-9 – volume: 58 start-page: 590 issue: 4 year: 2014 ident: 9759_CR14 publication-title: Comparative Education Review doi: 10.1086/677907 – ident: 9759_CR38 – volume: 27 start-page: 106 issue: 2 year: 2018 ident: 9759_CR27 publication-title: Research Evaluation doi: 10.1093/reseval/rvy001 – volume: 5 start-page: 225 issue: 3 year: 1992 ident: 9759_CR70 publication-title: Anxiety, Stress, and Coping doi: 10.1080/10615809208249524 – volume: 55 start-page: 316 issue: 3 year: 2020 ident: 9759_CR55 publication-title: European Journal of Education doi: 10.1111/ejed.12411 – volume: 106 start-page: 213 issue: 1 year: 2016 ident: 9759_CR67 publication-title: Scientometrics doi: 10.1007/s11192-015-1765-5 – start-page: 132 volume-title: Confronting the shadow education system: What government policies for what private tutoring? year: 2009 ident: 9759_CR6 – volume: 38 start-page: 24 year: 2014 ident: 9759_CR23 publication-title: Economics of Education Review doi: 10.1016/j.econedurev.2013.10.002 – volume-title: Education in a hidden marketplace: Monitoring of private tutoring year: 2006 ident: 9759_CR74 – ident: 9759_CR1 – volume-title: Private tutoring across the Mediterranean: Power dynamics and implications for learning and equity year: 2013 ident: 9759_CR22 – volume-title: Shadow education and the curriculum and culture of schooling in South Korea year: 2016 ident: 9759_CR52 doi: 10.1057/978-1-137-51324-3 – volume: 113 start-page: 614 year: 2017 ident: 9759_CR26 publication-title: Computers & Industrial Engineering doi: 10.1016/j.cie.2017.08.033 – volume: 5 start-page: 241 issue: 3 year: 1992 ident: 9759_CR71 publication-title: Anxiety, Stress, and Coping doi: 10.1080/10615809208249525 – volume: 30 start-page: 353 issue: 3 year: 2008 ident: 9759_CR80 publication-title: International Journal of Science Education doi: 10.1080/09500690701191425 – ident: 9759_CR104 doi: 10.1086/648186 – volume-title: Shadow education and social inequalities in Japan: Evolving patterns and conceptual implications year: 2018 ident: 9759_CR34 doi: 10.1007/978-3-319-69119-0 – volume-title: Teachers as tutors: Shadow education market dynamics in Georgia year: 2018 ident: 9759_CR54 doi: 10.1007/978-3-319-95915-3 – volume: 49 start-page: 1 issue: 1 year: 2012 ident: 9759_CR59 publication-title: Proceedings of the American Society for Information Science and Technology doi: 10.1002/meet.14504901027 – ident: 9759_CR111 doi: 10.4324/9781003317593 – volume: 31 start-page: 567 year: 2014 ident: 9759_CR29 publication-title: Procedia Computer Science doi: 10.1016/j.procs.2014.05.303 – volume: 61 start-page: 469 issue: 3 year: 2017 ident: 9759_CR9 publication-title: Comparative Education Review doi: 10.1086/692709 – volume-title: Shadow education: Private supplementary tutoring and its implications for policy makers in Asia year: 2012 ident: 9759_CR21 – year: 2021 ident: 9759_CR11 publication-title: Compare doi: 10.1080/03057925.2021.1915749 – start-page: 129 volume-title: Out of the shadows: The global intensification of supplementary education year: 2013 ident: 9759_CR82 doi: 10.1108/S1479-3679(2013)0000022006 – ident: 9759_CR110 doi: 10.1080/03057920903361926 – volume: 109 start-page: 1207 issue: 5 year: 2007 ident: 9759_CR57 publication-title: Teachers College Record doi: 10.1177/016146810710900507 – volume: 89 start-page: 435 issue: 2 year: 2010 ident: 9759_CR24 publication-title: Social Forces doi: 10.1353/sof.2010.0105 – volume: 32 start-page: 1 year: 2013 ident: 9759_CR91 publication-title: Economics of Education Review doi: 10.1016/j.econedurev.2012.09.008 – volume: 55 start-page: 311 issue: 3 year: 2020 ident: 9759_CR3 publication-title: European Journal of Education doi: 10.1111/ejed.12410 – volume: 55 start-page: 322 issue: 3 year: 2020 ident: 9759_CR90 publication-title: European Journal of Education doi: 10.1111/ejed.12413 – volume: 11 start-page: 411 issue: 3 year: 2010 ident: 9759_CR51 publication-title: Asia Pacific Education Review doi: 10.1007/s12564-009-9067-3 – volume: 4 start-page: 6 issue: 1 year: 2017 ident: 9759_CR62 publication-title: Social Sciences and Education Research Review – volume: 14 start-page: 5 issue: 2 year: 2020 ident: 9759_CR78 publication-title: Orbis Scholae doi: 10.14712/23363177.2020.17 – volume: 26 start-page: 323 issue: 3 year: 1994 ident: 9759_CR44 publication-title: Journal of Curriculum Studies doi: 10.1080/0022027940260307 – volume: 35 start-page: 1 issue: 1 year: 2009 ident: 9759_CR75 publication-title: Oxford Review of Education doi: 10.1080/03054980801981426 – ident: 9759_CR103 doi: 10.1007/s12564-009-9058-4 |
| SSID | ssj0063919 |
| Score | 2.432481 |
| Snippet | This study aims to map the literature on shadow education using metadata extracted from 488 publications indexed in the Web of Science database. It is termed... |
| SourceID | nrf pubmedcentral proquest eric crossref springer |
| SourceType | Open Website Open Access Repository Aggregation Database Index Database Enrichment Source Publisher |
| StartPage | 341 |
| SubjectTerms | Bibliometrics Education Educational Psychology Educational Research Educational Sociology Educational Trends Equal Education Pedagogy Periodicals Private Education Resistance (Psychology) Science Tutoring 교육학 |
| SummonAdditionalLinks | – databaseName: ProQuest Central dbid: BENPR link: http://utb.summon.serialssolutions.com/2.0.0/link/0/eLvHCXMwfV1Lb9QwELZoe-GCeFWkFGQJbqzFOmvHDhdU0FalEhVCVOoJy8_uqktSdhfx95lJnF1tJXrKIY7zmMnMN_bMN4S8DWAZdQ3IjQuZmJDWMc2lZs6XCtBzAiXD2uGvF9XZpTi_kld5wW2V0yoHm9gZ6tB6XCN_XwKyxW1FUX68_c2waxTuruYWGnvkAEywhuDr4NP04tv3wRaD--1ae4DPRhLTicplM33xHHh7wTCbfVwrWTOx45py9vNes0w74PNu6uSd_dPOLZ0-Jo8ynqQnvQI8IQ9i8xRbMee0jWfk5wl1c7fAKnsk46e_LDIyXNM20dXMhvYvjcNgmpl_Zh8opljGjkp8vRrRBVZB9Ut7I2qbQAE10p6N5Dm5PJ3--HzGclMF5oWSaxZ9cmAdRYySJ8AizoWx5cEnmarSj3nSdai1cla6qrQhgvuyEx6jFxNbBe0nh2S_aZv4gtA6Ks-rsauChbOAPFTF4csIVYYUtKwKwofvaXx-TGx8sTBbrmSUgQEZmE4GRhTk3eaa255v497RhyimzcjpOYbcACkL8gYEZ2783CB_Nh6vW3OzNBAlfMHZINLVcPnxIFiTf92V2SpaQdSOsDe3wSl3zzTzWUfNDdEr9mwvyGhQi-3E_3-No_uf4yV5WHZqims_x2R_vfwTXwEUWrvXWd__AYbpBNI priority: 102 providerName: ProQuest |
| Title | A bibliometric mapping of shadow education research: achievements, limitations, and the future |
| URI | https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s12564-022-09759-4 http://eric.ed.gov/ERICWebPortal/detail?accno=EJ1338522 https://www.proquest.com/docview/2675274242 https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/PMC8994526 https://www.kci.go.kr/kciportal/ci/sereArticleSearch/ciSereArtiView.kci?sereArticleSearchBean.artiId=ART002856233 |
| Volume | 23 |
| hasFullText | 1 |
| inHoldings | 1 |
| isFullTextHit | |
| isPrint | |
| ispartofPNX | Asia Pacific Education Review, 2022, 23(2), 74, pp.341-359 |
| link | http://utb.summon.serialssolutions.com/2.0.0/link/0/eLvHCXMwlV1LbxMxELZoe-GCyqMipUSW4EZWijf2epdbUiUtRUQIEalcsPxsooZNlQT173fG8SZKBUicfFh79jFezzf2zDeEvHewMpYVIDfGRci40CYrmSgzY3MJ6DnAJMPc4S_j4nLCr67FdUoKWzXR7s2RZFypd8luYJ15htHn3UqKKuMH5Eig7w6zeJL3m_UXTG4s5wF2GolLezKlyvxZxp45ShHPB_Uy7AHOx-GSj85MoykaHZNnCUPS_kbpz8kTX7_A8sspVOMl-dmnZmbmmFmPBPz0l0YWhhu6CHQ11W5xT33TmSa2n-lHimGVPtKHr1cdOsfMp812Xofq2lFAinTDQPKKTEbD7-eXWSqkkFkuxTrzNhhYEbn3ggXAH8a4rmbOBhGK3HZZKCtXldJoYYpcOw8mS_eY95b3dOFK2zshh_Wi9q8Jrby0rOiawmm4CmhDFgy-DJe5C64URYuw5nsqmx4Ti13M1Y4fGXWgQAcq6kDxFvmwHXO34dj4Z-8TVNO25_AK3WyAkS3yDhSnbu1MIWc2tjcLdbtU4Bl8Qmng3ZYw_KxRrEq_60rl4DbhmTUHIXJP2dvboMj9K_VsGum4wWPFOu0t0mmmxU7w31_j9P-6vyFP8zhtcf_njByul7_9W4BDa9MmR_3RYDDG9uLH5yG0g-H467d23Apox3_jAZL8Bho |
| linkProvider | Springer Nature |
| linkToHtml | http://utb.summon.serialssolutions.com/2.0.0/link/0/eLvHCXMwtV1Lb9NAEB616QEuqDwqDAVWAk7EIrbXLySECqRK-ogQaqWeWPbZRE3tkgRV_Cl-IzN-JEoleuvJB--u7Z3x7De7M98AvDFoGbMckVvAY-fzWCo_C-LMVzpMET07VDLKHT4eJYNTfnAWn23A3zYXhsIqW5tYGWpTatojfx8isqVjRR5-uvrlU9UoOl1tS2jUanFo_1yjyzb_OPyK8n0bhvv9ky8Dv6kq4GuexgvfaqfQPHBr48DhYqyU6cnAaBe7JNS9wGW5QUdcyVgloTQW7beMAms1j2RiMh3huJuwxSN0ZTqw9bk_-va9tf243FelRBAjEGlqlDZpOnWyHqIL7lP0fC9P49zna0thE229WczcGti9Gap547y2Wgb3t-FBg1_ZXq1wD2HDFo-o9HMTJvIYfuwxNVFTyuon8n92KYkB4pyVjs3H0pTXzLaNWcM0NP7AKKTTVtTli3mXTSnrqt5K7DJZGIYoldXsJ0_g9E6mewc6RVnYp8Bym-og6anESLyLSCdNApwZnobGmSxOPAja-RS6eU0qtDEVK25mkoFAGYhKBoJ78G7Z56rm97i19Q6Jadmyf0AuPkJYD16j4MSFngji66breSkuZgK9kiGNhp51ht13W8GKxlTMxUqxPUjXhL18DA25fqeYjCsqcPSWqUa8B91WLVYD__8znt3-Hq_g3uDk-EgcDUeHz-F-WKks7TvtQmcx-21fIAxbqJeN7jP4ede_2z_zfUQd |
| linkToPdf | http://utb.summon.serialssolutions.com/2.0.0/link/0/eLvHCXMwtV1Lb9NAEF61qYS4oPKoMBRYCTgRq7az6wcSQoUmalqIKkSlnlj22URN7ZIEVfw1fh0z9jpRKtFbTzl4vbF3xjPf7M58Q8gbA5YxLwC5xYy7kHGpwjzmeah0kgF6dqBkWDv8dZQenrKjM362Qf62tTCYVtnaxNpQm0rjHvleAsgWjxVZsud8WsTJweDj1a8QO0jhSWvbTqNRkWP75xrCt_mH4QHI-m2SDPrfPx-GvsNAqFnGF6HVToGpYNby2IFjVspEMjbacZcmOopdXhgIypXkKk2ksWDLZS-2VrOeTE2uezDvJtnKICqKOmTrU3908q31A-D667YigBeQQLWX-ZKdpnAPkAYLMZM-KjJehGzNLfrM681y5taA7820zRtnt7VLHGyTBx7L0v1G-R6SDVs-wjbQPmXkMfmxT9VETbHCHxsB0EuJbBDntHJ0Ppamuqa2HUw969D4PcX0TlvTmC_mXTrFCqxmW7FLZWkoIFbaMKE8Iad3stw7pFNWpX1KaGEzHaeRSo2Eq4B6sjSGlWFZYpzJeRqQuF1Pof1jYtONqVjxNKMMBMhA1DIQLCDvlvdcNVwft47eQTEtR_aPMNwHOBuQ1yA4caEnArm78fe8EhczARHKEGeDKDuH23dbwQpvNuZipeQBydaEvfwbnHL9SjkZ17TgEDljv_iAdFu1WE38_9d4dvtzvCL34DMTX4aj4-fkflJrLG5B7ZLOYvbbvgBEtlAvvepT8vOuv7Z_BPFIUg |
| openUrl | ctx_ver=Z39.88-2004&ctx_enc=info%3Aofi%2Fenc%3AUTF-8&rfr_id=info%3Asid%2Fsummon.serialssolutions.com&rft_val_fmt=info%3Aofi%2Ffmt%3Akev%3Amtx%3Ajournal&rft.genre=article&rft.atitle=A+bibliometric+mapping+of+shadow+education+research%3A+achievements%2C+limitations%2C+and+the+future&rft.jtitle=Asia+Pacific+education+review&rft.au=Hajar%2C+Anas&rft.au=Karakus%2C+Mehmet&rft.date=2022-06-01&rft.pub=Springer+Netherlands&rft.issn=1598-1037&rft.eissn=1876-407X&rft.volume=23&rft.issue=2&rft.spage=341&rft.epage=359&rft_id=info:doi/10.1007%2Fs12564-022-09759-4&rft.externalDocID=10_1007_s12564_022_09759_4 |
| thumbnail_l | http://covers-cdn.summon.serialssolutions.com/index.aspx?isbn=/lc.gif&issn=1598-1037&client=summon |
| thumbnail_m | http://covers-cdn.summon.serialssolutions.com/index.aspx?isbn=/mc.gif&issn=1598-1037&client=summon |
| thumbnail_s | http://covers-cdn.summon.serialssolutions.com/index.aspx?isbn=/sc.gif&issn=1598-1037&client=summon |