Translation of patients’ advance directives in intensive care units: are we there yet?

• Published in: Journal of intensive care Vol. 11; no. 1; pp. 1 - 53
• Main Authors: Baumann, Sira M, Kruse, Natalie J, Kliem, Paulina S. C, Amacher, Simon A, Hunziker, Sabina, Dittrich, Tolga D, Renetseder, Fabienne, Grzonka, Pascale, Sutter, Raoul
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: London BioMed Central Ltd 15.11.2023; BioMed Central; BMC
• Subjects: Advance directives; Advertising executives; Cancer; Cohort analysis; Cross-sectional studies; Decision making; Do-not-resuscitate orders; Health care; Hospitals; Illnesses; Intensive care; Medical law; Medical personnel; Neurocritical illness; Palliative treatment; Patient compliance; Patients; Patients’ will; Systematic review; Germany; United States > US
• ISSN: 2052-0492; 2052-0492
• DOI: 10.1186/s40560-023-00705-z

Objectives This review examined studies regarding the implementation and translation of patients' advance directives (AD) in intensive care units (ICUs), focusing on practical difficulties and obstacles. Methods The digital PubMed and Medline databases were screened using predefined keywords to identify relevant prospective and retrospective studies published until 2022. Results Seventeen studies from the United States, Europe, and South Africa (including 149,413 patients and 1210 healthcare professionals) were identified. The highest prevalence of ADs was described in a prospective study in North America (49%), followed by Central Europe (13%), Asia (4%), Australia and New Zealand (4%), Latin America (3%), and Northern and Southern Europe (2.6%). While four retrospective studies reported limited effects of ADs, four retrospective studies, one survey and one systematic review indicated significant effects on provision of intensive care, higher rates of do-not-resuscitate orders, and care withholding in patients with ADs. Four of these studies showed shorter ICU stays, and lower treatment costs in patients with ADs. One prospective and two retrospective studies reported issues with loss, delayed or no transmission of ADs. One survey revealed that 91% of healthcare workers did not regularly check for ADs. Two retrospective studies and two survey revealed that the implementation of directives is further challenged by issues with their applicability, phrasing, and compliance by the critical care team and family members. Conclusions Although ADs may improve intensive- and end-of-life care, insufficient knowledge, lack of awareness, poor communication between healthcare providers and patients or surrogates, lack of standardization of directives, as well as ethical and legal concerns challenge their implementation. Keywords: Advance directives, Patients' will, Intensive care, Neurocritical illness