Learning about physical parameters: the importance of model discrepancy

• Published in: Inverse problems Vol. 30; no. 11; pp. 114007 - 114030
• Main Authors: Brynjarsdottir, Jenny, OHagan, Anthony
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: IOP Publishing 01.11.2014
• Subjects: Accounting; Calibration; computer models; Computer simulation; extrapolation; Gaussian; Inverse problems; Learning; Mathematical models; model form error; Physical properties; simulation model; structural uncertainty; uncertainty quantification
• ISSN: 0266-5611; 1361-6420
• DOI: 10.1088/0266-5611/30/11/114007

Science-based simulation models are widely used to predict the behavior of complex physical systems. It is also common to use observations of the physical system to solve the inverse problem, that is, to learn about the values of parameters within the model, a process which is often called calibration. The main goal of calibration is usually to improve the predictive performance of the simulator but the values of the parameters in the model may also be of intrinsic scientific interest in their own right. In order to make appropriate use of observations of the physical system it is important to recognize model discrepancy, the difference between reality and the simulator output. We illustrate through a simple example that an analysis that does not account for model discrepancy may lead to biased and over-confident parameter estimates and predictions. The challenge with incorporating model discrepancy in statistical inverse problems is being confounded with calibration parameters, which will only be resolved with meaningful priors. For our simple example, we model the model-discrepancy via a Gaussian process and demonstrate that through accounting for model discrepancy our prediction within the range of data is correct. However, only with realistic priors on the model discrepancy do we uncover the true parameter values. Through theoretical arguments we show that these findings are typical of the general problem of learning about physical parameters and the underlying physical system using science-based mechanistic models.