Unravelling the clonal trait space: Beyond above‐ground and fine‐root traits

• Published in: The Journal of ecology Vol. 112; no. 4; pp. 730 - 740
• Main Authors: Chelli, Stefano, Klimešová, Jitka, Tsakalos, James Lee, Puglielli, Giacomo
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Oxford Blackwell Publishing Ltd 01.04.2024
• Subjects: bud bank; data collection; ecology; Economics; fine roots; functional strategy; functional trait space; Herbs; life history traits; perennial herbs; plant architecture; plant clonality; Plants; species; trait coordination
• ISSN: 0022-0477; 1365-2745
• DOI: 10.1111/1365-2745.14265

Plant trait variation is constrained by mechanical and energetic trade‐offs as attested by the global spectrum of plant form and function and the fine‐root economics space for above‐ and below‐ground traits. However, traits that are key for fitness maintenance in some plant groups, such as clonal and bud bank traits, have not yet been integrated within the frameworks provided by the above‐ground and the fine‐root economics space. By using an extensive dataset encompassing above‐ground, fine‐root, clonal and bud bank traits of 2000 species of Central European herbs, we asked whether clonal and bud bank traits correspond to the placement of species in the above‐ground or fine‐root trait space. Perennial clonal and non‐clonal herbs show indistinct positioning within the above‐ground and fine‐root trait spaces. This extends and reinforces previous fragmentary evidence of weak correlations between clonal and bud bank traits and above‐ground trait dimensions. Additionally, we identify for the first time a limited correlation between clonal and fine‐root traits as well. This disconnection suggests that clonal traits operate independently from other trait spectra. For this reason, we introduce the concept of a ‘clonal trait space’ for clonal herbs. The first dimension of this space is defined by bud bank size and the persistence of clonal connection, reflecting a gradient of species specialisation for on‐spot persistence and tolerance to disturbance (persistence dimension). The second dimension, defined by multiplication rate and lateral spread, reflects a specialisation axis for clonal multiplication and horizontal size dimension (clonal multiplication dimension). Clonal trait dimensions add non‐redundant information to the above‐ground or fine‐roots trait space. Synthesis: We champion the integration of the persistence and clonal multiplication dimensions from the ‘clonal trait space’ into the frameworks provided by the above‐ground trait and the fine‐root economics spaces, thereby enhancing our comprehension of the multifaceted trait strategies exhibited by plants. The authors found that clonal and bud bank traits operate independently from traits of the spectrum of plant form and function and the fine‐root economics space. Therefore, they introduced the concept of a ‘clonal trait space’ for clonal herbs. The first dimension of this trait space reflects a gradient of specialisation for on‐spot persistence and tolerance to disturbance (persistence dimension). The second dimension reflects a specialisation axis for clonal multiplication and horizontal size dimension (clonal multiplication dimension).