Fishy business in Seattle: Salmon mislabeling fraud in sushi restaurants vs grocery stores

• Published in: PloS one Vol. 19; no. 11; p. e0311522
• Main Authors: Garcia, Jewel L, Gaspar, Yennifer A, Djekoundade, Angelique, Dalere, Mhicca, Al-awadi, Asmaa A, Allossogbe, Marjolene, Allossogbe, Thania C. P, Aparicio, Itzel S, Buller, Hannah N, Cadelina, Hera Beatrice F, Camarillo, Isabella K, Case, Kayla, Dean, Abigail E, Dean, Sara M, DeJong, Jordyn F, Delgado, Elizabeth, Dupar, Renske J, Ely, Emma N, Ewing, Mia C, Filli, Delina N, Fleming, Spencer E, Garrett, Mackenzie R, Graves, Blair P, Hafez, Marie M, Hanson, Weston P, Heller, Alexander D, Hernandez, Anthony J, Horton, Elizabeth K, Jancola, Ellie G, Keith, Lauryn A, Knoke, Madison J, Larkin, Jared D, Marineau, Andre' G, Martin-Ortiz, Fabiola, Mayer, Olivia L, Mendoza, Yolanda M, Nalivayko, Peter V, Nguyen, Nguyen, Nguyen, Eloisa T, Nguyen, Henry, Ovenell, Griffin L, Paw, Lay G, Raymond, Spencer R, Redzic, Janetta J, Rice, Madelyn T, Rodrigo, Ashlie T, Savell, Jonathan M, Sheirbon, Ben R, Torres, Dulce S, Warrick, Kalena A, Long, Eric S, Nelson, Timothy A, Delgado, Tracie
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: San Francisco Public Library of Science 06.11.2024
• Subjects: Agricultural economics; Aquaculture; Biology and Life Sciences; Coasts; Commercial fishing; Consumption; Customers; Cytochrome-c oxidase; Earth Sciences; Economic impact; Economics; Fish; Fish as food; Fisheries management; Fishing; Fraud; Grocery industry; Grocery stores; Labeling; Labels; Legislation; Management; Native species; Nucleotide sequence; People and places; Research and Analysis Methods; Restaurants; Salmon; Seafood; Social Sciences; Sustainable fisheries; Sustainable practices; Trout; United States; Pacific Ocean; Puget Sound; United States > US; Pacific Northwest
• DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0311522
• ISSN: 1932-6203

Salmon is the most commonly consumed finfish in the United States of America (USA), and the mislabeling of salmon is a widespread problem. Washington State is a global supplier of wild-caught Pacific salmon and local salmon mislabeling results in substantial economic, ecological, and cultural impacts. Previous studies in Washington State identified high levels of mislabeled salmon in both markets and restaurants, resulting in local legislation being passed that requires proper labeling of salmon products, including identifying it as wild-caught or farm-raised. To investigate whether recent legislative efforts reduced salmon fraud rates, we acquired and genetically barcoded salmon samples from 67 grocery stores and 52 sushi restaurants in Seattle, Washington. DNA from each salmon sample was isolated and the cytochrome c oxidase gene was sequenced to identify the fish species. Our study, conducted from 2022–2023, revealed 18% of salmon samples from both grocery stores and sushi restaurants were mislabeled. While most samples were acquired during the fall months when wild salmon is in season, we still observed a high salmon mislabeling rate. Unlike grocery stores, Seattle sushi restaurants often sold farmed salmon mislabeled as wild salmon. Specifically, substitutions of vendor-claimed wild salmon with farmed salmon occurred in 32.3% of sushi restaurant samples compared to 0% of grocery store samples. Additionally, occurrences of wild salmon being substituted with another salmon species (wild or farmed) occurred in 38.7% of sushi restaurant samples compared to 11.1% of grocery store samples. All salmon substitutions in sushi restaurants harmed the customer financially as they were given a cheaper market-priced fish. In grocery stores, however, we did not detect significant economic loss to customers due to salmon mislabeling. Taken together, it is important to continue to develop and enforce legislation in Washington State that prevents salmon fraud and promotes ecologically sustainable fishing practices.