Insulin purification—Innovation continuum via synthesis of fundamentals, technology, and modeling

• Published in: Biotechnology and bioengineering Vol. 121; no. 8; pp. 2409 - 2422
• Main Authors: Roush, David, Iammarino, Michael, Chmielowski, Rebecca, Insaidoo, Francis, McCoy, Mark A., Ortigosa, Allison, Rauscher, Michael
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: United States Wiley Subscription Services, Inc 01.08.2024
• Subjects: Biological products; Biopharmaceuticals; Biophysics; Biotechnology - methods; Case studies; Complexity; computational biophysics; computational developability; Crystallization; Crystals; E coli; Foaming agents; Historical structures; Humans; Inclusion bodies; innovation; Innovations; Insulin; Insulin - chemistry; Insulin - isolation & purification; Insulin - metabolism; Ligands; Lysis; Molecular modelling; Oligomerization; Parameter identification; Process intensification; Protein purification; Proteins; Purification; Recovery; Software; Solubilization; innovation; computational biophysics; computational developability; crystallization; insulin
• ISSN: 0006-3592; 1097-0290; 1097-0290
• DOI: 10.1002/bit.28427

Advancement in all disciplines (art, science, education, and engineering) requires a careful balance of disruption and advancement of classical techniques. Often technologies are created with a limited understanding of fundamental principles and are prematurely abandoned. Over time, knowledge improves, new opportunities are identified, and technology is reassessed in a different light leading to a renaissance. Recovery of biological products is currently experiencing such a renaissance. Crystallization is one example of an elegant and ancient technology that has been applied in many fields and was employed to purify insulins from naturally occurring sources. Crystallization can also be utilized to determine protein structures. However, a multitude of parameters can impact protein crystallization and the “hit rate” for identifying protein crystals is relatively low, so much so that the development of a crystallization process is often viewed as a combination of art and science even today. Supplying the worldwide requirement for insulin (and associated variants) requires significant advances in process intensification to support scale of production and to minimize the overall cost to enable broader access. Expanding beyond insulin, the increasing complexity and diversity of biologics agents challenge the current purification methodologies. To harness the full potential of biologics, there is a need to fully explore a broader range of purification technologies, including nonchromatographic approaches. This impetus requires one to challenge and revisit the classical techniques including crystallization, chromatography, and filtration from a different vantage point and with a new set of tools, including molecular modeling. Fortunately, computational biophysics tools now exist to provide insights into mechanisms of protein/ligand interactions and molecular assembly processes (including crystallization) that can be used to support de novo process development. For example, specific regions or motifs of insulins and ligands can be identified and used as targets to support crystallization or purification development. Although the modeling tools have been developed and validated for insulin systems, the same tools can be applied to more complex modalities and to other areas including formulation, where the issue of aggregation and concentration‐dependent oligomerization could be mechanistically modeled. This paper will illustrate a case study juxtaposing historical approaches to insulin downstream processes to a recent production process highlighting the application and evolution of technologies. Insulin production from Escherichia coli via inclusion bodies is an elegant example since it incorporates virtually all the unit operations associated with protein production—recovery of cells, lysis, solubilization, refolding, purification, and crystallization. The case study will include an example of an innovative application of existing membrane technology to combine three‐unit operations into one, significantly reducing solids handling and buffer consumption. Ironically, a new separations technology was developed over the course of the case study that could further simplify and intensify the downstream process, emphasizing and highlighting the ever‐accelerating pace of innovation in downstream processing. Molecular biophysics modeling was also employed to enhance the mechanistic understanding of the crystallization and purification processes. A continuum of innovation applies to process development, including time and scale. Case studies are summarized that highlight the juxtaposition of technologies between historical and recent insulin production processes. Insulin production from E. coli via inclusion bodies is an elegant example since it incorporates many unit operations associated with protein production–recovery of cells, lysis, solubilization, refolding, purification, and crystallization. New technologies (ex. computational biophysics tools and LC/MS) now exist to provide insights into mechanisms to support de novo process development.