Justice in waiting: The harms and wrongs of temporary refugee protection

Temporariness has become the norm in contemporary refugee protection. Many refugees face extended periods of time waiting for permanent status, either in camps or living among citizens in their state of asylum. Whilst this practice of keeping refugees waiting is of benefit to states, I argue that no...

Full description

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Published inEuropean journal of political theory Vol. 22; no. 1; pp. 51 - 72
Main Author Buxton, Rebecca
Format Journal Article
LanguageEnglish
Published London, England SAGE Publications 01.01.2023
Sage Publications Ltd
Subjects
Online AccessGet full text

Cover

Loading…
Abstract Temporariness has become the norm in contemporary refugee protection. Many refugees face extended periods of time waiting for permanent status, either in camps or living among citizens in their state of asylum. Whilst this practice of keeping refugees waiting is of benefit to states, I argue that not only is it harmful to refugees but it also constitutes an injustice. First, I outline the prevalence of temporary assistance in the refugee protection regime. Second, I outline the orthodox view on temporary refugee protection – it is acceptable as long as it is not indefinite. I then spend the remainder of the article considering four arguments against temporary refugee protection: the plan argument, the reciprocity argument, the domination argument, and the compounding injustice argument. I contend that the first two arguments, which already feature in the literature, merely show that temporary protection is harmful to refugees. My own arguments on domination and compounding injustice show, instead, that giving refugees temporary protection constitutes an injustice. The domination argument allows us to critique the current practice of temporary refugee protection, whereas the compounding injustice argument shows that temporariness in any form constitutes an injustice.
AbstractList Temporariness has become the norm in contemporary refugee protection. Many refugees face extended periods of time waiting for permanent status, either in camps or living among citizens in their state of asylum. Whilst this practice of keeping refugees waiting is of benefit to states, I argue that not only is it harmful to refugees but it also constitutes an injustice. First, I outline the prevalence of temporary assistance in the refugee protection regime. Second, I outline the orthodox view on temporary refugee protection – it is acceptable as long as it is not indefinite. I then spend the remainder of the article considering four arguments against temporary refugee protection: the plan argument, the reciprocity argument, the domination argument, and the compounding injustice argument. I contend that the first two arguments, which already feature in the literature, merely show that temporary protection is harmful to refugees. My own arguments on domination and compounding injustice show, instead, that giving refugees temporary protection constitutes an injustice. The domination argument allows us to critique the current practice of temporary refugee protection, whereas the compounding injustice argument shows that temporariness in any form constitutes an injustice.
Author Buxton, Rebecca
Author_xml – sequence: 1
  givenname: Rebecca
  orcidid: 0000-0002-4518-5307
  surname: Buxton
  fullname: Buxton, Rebecca
  email: rebecca.buxton@sjc.ox.ac.uk
  organization: , UK
BookMark eNp1kM1LxDAQxYOs4O7q3WPAc3Xy0Sb1Jou6yoKX9VzSNu12sUlNUhb_e1MqCIKneTC_efNmVmhhrNEIXRO4JUSIO8IFlzIlFHLBUiHP0JIIThIqGCyiju1k6l-glfdHgMhxtkTb19GHrtK4M_ikutCZ9h7vDxoflOs9VqbGJ2dN67FtcND9YJ1yX9jpZmy1xoOzQVehs-YSnTfqw-urn7pG70-P-8022b09v2wedknFUhKSpoSq1qqWkuVZTkVOS6lKQmXGoBRl00BZs5wSyUU6aUIFSGBUpYwznkm2Rjezb1z9OWofiqMdnYkri3hqDjTlkkcKZqpy1vuYthhc18fkBYFi-lfx919xJJlHvGr1r-m__De6UWqb
CitedBy_id crossref_primary_10_1080_13698230_2021_1880198
crossref_primary_10_1086_723990
crossref_primary_10_1080_17449626_2023_2271001
crossref_primary_10_1111_japp_12718
crossref_primary_10_1080_15562948_2023_2289116
crossref_primary_10_1111_japp_12750
crossref_primary_10_1111_1440_1630_12756
crossref_primary_10_1111_japp_12720
crossref_primary_10_1177_00323217241238124
Cites_doi 10.1017/CBO9780511626845
10.2307/j.ctvjhzr8r
10.1080/13621025.2020.1722412
10.1080/713604489
10.1111/j.1747-7379.2001.tb00003.x
10.1093/ijrl/13.4.533
10.1017/CBO9781139017428
10.1111/j.1747-7093.2003.tb00421.x
10.1093/acprof:oso/9780190222246.001.0001
10.1017/9781316671443
10.1017/S0265052517000097
10.17265/2159-5313/2016.09.003
10.1017/CBO9780511490248
10.4159/9780674969827
10.1007/978-94-6265-060-2_9
10.1111/papa.12018
10.1080/13698230.2019.1573347
10.1093/jrs/7.2-3.160
10.1111/jopp.12071
10.1111/j.1747-7093.2008.00141.x
10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199278268.001.0001
10.1080/13698230.2020.1722920
ContentType Journal Article
Copyright The Author(s) 2020
Copyright_xml – notice: The Author(s) 2020
DBID AFRWT
AAYXX
CITATION
7UB
DOI 10.1177/1474885120973578
DatabaseName SAGE Open Access Journals
CrossRef
Worldwide Political Science Abstracts
DatabaseTitle CrossRef
Worldwide Political Science Abstracts
DatabaseTitleList CrossRef
Worldwide Political Science Abstracts

Database_xml – sequence: 1
  dbid: AFRWT
  name: Sage Journals GOLD Open Access 2024
  url: http://journals.sagepub.com/
  sourceTypes: Publisher
DeliveryMethod fulltext_linktorsrc
Discipline Political Science
EISSN 1741-2730
EndPage 72
ExternalDocumentID 10_1177_1474885120973578
10.1177_1474885120973578
GrantInformation_xml – fundername: Economic and Social Research Council
  funderid: https://doi.org/10.13039/501100000269
GroupedDBID -MK
-TM
-~X
.2L
01A
0R~
1XV
1~K
29G
2A-
31W
31X
4.4
56W
5GY
5VS
AABOD
AADIR
AADUE
AAJPV
AAOYI
AAQDB
AARIX
AATAA
ABAWP
ABCCA
ABEIX
ABFXH
ABHQH
ABJNI
ABKRH
ABPNF
ABQPY
ABQXT
ABRHV
ACDXX
ACFUR
ACFZE
ACGFS
ACLZU
ACOFE
ACOXC
ACROE
ACSIQ
ACTQU
ACUIR
ADINF
ADRRZ
ADTOS
AEOBU
AESZF
AEUHG
AEUIJ
AEVPJ
AEWDL
AEWHI
AEXNY
AFEET
AFKRG
AFMOU
AFQAA
AFRWT
AFUIA
AGDVU
AGKLV
AGNHF
AGNWV
AHHFK
AHWHD
AIOMO
AJUZI
ALJHS
ALMA_UNASSIGNED_HOLDINGS
ALNCK
ANDLU
ARTOV
ASPBG
AUTPY
AUVAJ
AVWKF
AYPQM
AZFZN
B8T
B8Z
BDZRT
BMVBW
BPACV
BYIEH
CAG
CEADM
COF
CS3
DG~
DOPDO
DV7
DV8
EBS
EJD
FEDTE
FHBDP
GROUPED_SAGE_PREMIER_JOURNAL_COLLECTION
HF~
HVGLF
HZ~
J8X
JCYGO
M4V
N9A
O9-
P.B
P2P
Q7P
RIG
ROL
S01
SCNPE
SFC
SFI
SFK
SFT
SFX
SGU
SGV
SHB
SPJ
SPK
SPP
SSDHQ
TN5
ZPLXX
ZPPRI
~32
AAYXX
ACJER
ACRPL
ADYCS
AEDXQ
AGWNL
CITATION
H13
7UB
ID FETCH-LOGICAL-c351t-fb0cdead8839692792b8ab128630b7bff0bd39218475f0bd12708032a53434683
IEDL.DBID AFRWT
ISSN 1474-8851
IngestDate Thu Oct 10 17:40:32 EDT 2024
Fri Dec 06 07:18:57 EST 2024
Tue Jul 16 20:37:41 EDT 2024
IsDoiOpenAccess true
IsOpenAccess true
IsPeerReviewed true
IsScholarly true
Issue 1
Keywords justice
domination
temporary protection
Asylum
refugee
Language English
License This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) which permits any use, reproduction and distribution of the work without further permission provided the original work is attributed as specified on the SAGE and Open Access pages (https://us.sagepub.com/en-us/nam/open-access-at-sage).
LinkModel DirectLink
MergedId FETCHMERGED-LOGICAL-c351t-fb0cdead8839692792b8ab128630b7bff0bd39218475f0bd12708032a53434683
ORCID 0000-0002-4518-5307
OpenAccessLink https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/1474885120973578?utm_source=summon&utm_medium=discovery-provider
PQID 2739025484
PQPubID 2039634
PageCount 22
ParticipantIDs proquest_journals_2739025484
crossref_primary_10_1177_1474885120973578
sage_journals_10_1177_1474885120973578
PublicationCentury 2000
PublicationDate 20230100
2023-01-00
20230101
PublicationDateYYYYMMDD 2023-01-01
PublicationDate_xml – month: 1
  year: 2023
  text: 20230100
PublicationDecade 2020
PublicationPlace London, England
PublicationPlace_xml – name: London, England
– name: London
PublicationTitle European journal of political theory
PublicationYear 2023
Publisher SAGE Publications
Sage Publications Ltd
Publisher_xml – name: SAGE Publications
– name: Sage Publications Ltd
References Carens 2008; 22
Ronzoni 2017; 34
Allain 2001; 13
Stilz 2013; 41
Birnie 2020; 24
Carens 2003; 17
Cherem 2016; 24
Loescher 2001; 35
Pugh 2001; 6
Durieux 2014; 45
Warner 1994; 7
bibr41-1474885120973578
bibr16-1474885120973578
bibr3-1474885120973578
bibr11-1474885120973578
bibr29-1474885120973578
bibr8-1474885120973578
bibr25-1474885120973578
bibr17-1474885120973578
bibr38-1474885120973578
bibr117-1474885120973578
bibr32-1474885120973578
bibr15-1474885120973578
bibr42-1474885120973578
bibr28-1474885120973578
bibr6-1474885120973578
bibr12-1474885120973578
bibr7-1474885120973578
bibr37-1474885120973578
bibr2-1474885120973578
bibr33-1474885120973578
Carens J (bibr5-1474885120973578) 2013
Hathaway J (bibr18-1474885120973578) 2001
bibr20-1474885120973578
bibr14-1474885120973578
bibr1-1474885120973578
bibr43-1474885120973578
bibr30-1474885120973578
bibr19-1474885120973578
bibr21-1474885120973578
Laborde C (bibr22-1474885120973578) 2008
Pettit P (bibr27-1474885120973578) 1997
bibr36-1474885120973578
bibr34-1474885120973578
bibr4-1474885120973578
bibr10-1474885120973578
bibr39-1474885120973578
bibr23-1474885120973578
Lovett F (bibr24-1474885120973578) 2011
bibr26-1474885120973578
bibr9-1474885120973578
bibr40-1474885120973578
bibr31-1474885120973578
bibr35-1474885120973578
Feinberg J (bibr13-1474885120973578) 1987
References_xml – volume: 24
  start-page: 183
  issue: 2
  year: 2016
  end-page: 205
  article-title: Refugee rights: Against expanding the definition of a ‘refugee’ and unilateral protection elsewhere
  publication-title: Journal of Political Philosophy
  contributor:
    fullname: Cherem
– volume: 34
  start-page: 186
  issue: 1
  year: 2017
  end-page: 208
  article-title: Republicanism and global institutions: Three desiderata in tension
  publication-title: Social Philosophy and Policy
  contributor:
    fullname: Ronzoni
– volume: 7
  issue: 2–3
  year: 1994
  article-title: Voluntary repatriation and the meaning of return to home: A critique of liberal mathematics
  publication-title: Journal of Refugee Studies
  contributor:
    fullname: Warner
– volume: 13
  start-page: 533
  issue: 4
  year: 2001
  end-page: 558
  article-title: The jus cogens nature of non‐refoulement
  publication-title: International Journal of Refugee Law
  contributor:
    fullname: Allain
– volume: 22
  start-page: 163
  issue: 2
  year: 2008
  end-page: 186
  article-title: The rights of irregular migrants
  publication-title: Ethics & International Affairs
  contributor:
    fullname: Carens
– volume: 45
  start-page: 221
  year: 2014
  end-page: 253
  article-title: Temporary protection: Hovering at the edges of refugee law
  publication-title: Netherlands Yearbook of International Law
  contributor:
    fullname: Durieux
– volume: 24
  start-page: 371
  issue: 3
  year: 2020
  end-page: 388
  article-title: Citizenship, domicile and deportability: Who should be exempt from the state’s power to expel?
  publication-title: Citizenship Studies
  contributor:
    fullname: Birnie
– volume: 41
  start-page: 324
  issue: 4
  year: 2013
  end-page: 356
  article-title: Occupancy rights and the wrong of removal
  publication-title: Philosophy and Public Affairs
  contributor:
    fullname: Stilz
– volume: 6
  start-page: 1
  year: 2001
  end-page: 20
  publication-title: Mediterranean Politics
  contributor:
    fullname: Pugh
– volume: 35
  start-page: 33
  year: 2001
  end-page: 56
  article-title: The UNHCR and world politics: State interests vs. institutional autonomy.
  publication-title: The International Migration Review
  contributor:
    fullname: Loescher
– volume: 17
  start-page: 95
  issue: 1
  year: 2003
  end-page: 110
  article-title: Who should get in? The ethics of immigration admissions
  publication-title: Ethics & International Affairs
  contributor:
    fullname: Carens
– ident: bibr29-1474885120973578
  doi: 10.1017/CBO9780511626845
– volume-title: The Moral Limits of Criminal Law
  year: 1987
  ident: bibr13-1474885120973578
  contributor:
    fullname: Feinberg J
– ident: bibr34-1474885120973578
  doi: 10.2307/j.ctvjhzr8r
– ident: bibr30-1474885120973578
– ident: bibr38-1474885120973578
– ident: bibr2-1474885120973578
  doi: 10.1080/13621025.2020.1722412
– volume-title: Republicanism: A Theory of Freedom and Government
  year: 1997
  ident: bibr27-1474885120973578
  contributor:
    fullname: Pettit P
– ident: bibr8-1474885120973578
– ident: bibr31-1474885120973578
  doi: 10.1080/713604489
– volume-title: The Ethics of Immigration
  year: 2013
  ident: bibr5-1474885120973578
  contributor:
    fullname: Carens J
– ident: bibr23-1474885120973578
  doi: 10.1111/j.1747-7379.2001.tb00003.x
– ident: bibr33-1474885120973578
– ident: bibr11-1474885120973578
– ident: bibr19-1474885120973578
– ident: bibr14-1474885120973578
– ident: bibr16-1474885120973578
– ident: bibr1-1474885120973578
  doi: 10.1093/ijrl/13.4.533
– ident: bibr28-1474885120973578
  doi: 10.1017/CBO9781139017428
– ident: bibr36-1474885120973578
– ident: bibr3-1474885120973578
  doi: 10.1111/j.1747-7093.2003.tb00421.x
– ident: bibr26-1474885120973578
  doi: 10.1093/acprof:oso/9780190222246.001.0001
– ident: bibr43-1474885120973578
  doi: 10.1017/9781316671443
– ident: bibr32-1474885120973578
  doi: 10.1017/S0265052517000097
– ident: bibr12-1474885120973578
  doi: 10.17265/2159-5313/2016.09.003
– ident: bibr20-1474885120973578
– ident: bibr17-1474885120973578
  doi: 10.1017/CBO9780511490248
– ident: bibr25-1474885120973578
  doi: 10.4159/9780674969827
– ident: bibr10-1474885120973578
  doi: 10.1007/978-94-6265-060-2_9
– ident: bibr35-1474885120973578
  doi: 10.1111/papa.12018
– ident: bibr39-1474885120973578
– ident: bibr40-1474885120973578
– ident: bibr15-1474885120973578
  doi: 10.1080/13698230.2019.1573347
– ident: bibr41-1474885120973578
  doi: 10.1093/jrs/7.2-3.160
– ident: bibr6-1474885120973578
  doi: 10.1111/jopp.12071
– ident: bibr4-1474885120973578
  doi: 10.1111/j.1747-7093.2008.00141.x
– ident: bibr117-1474885120973578
– ident: bibr42-1474885120973578
  doi: 10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199278268.001.0001
– ident: bibr7-1474885120973578
– volume-title: Republicanism and Political Theory
  year: 2008
  ident: bibr22-1474885120973578
  contributor:
    fullname: Laborde C
– ident: bibr9-1474885120973578
  doi: 10.1080/13698230.2020.1722920
– ident: bibr21-1474885120973578
– start-page: 41
  volume-title: Perspectives on Refugee Protection in South Africa
  year: 2001
  ident: bibr18-1474885120973578
  contributor:
    fullname: Hathaway J
– volume-title: A General Theory of Domination and Justice
  year: 2011
  ident: bibr24-1474885120973578
  contributor:
    fullname: Lovett F
– ident: bibr37-1474885120973578
SSID ssj0020943
Score 2.3838058
Snippet Temporariness has become the norm in contemporary refugee protection. Many refugees face extended periods of time waiting for permanent status, either in camps...
SourceID proquest
crossref
sage
SourceType Aggregation Database
Publisher
StartPage 51
SubjectTerms Dominance
Injustice
Political asylum
Refugees
Welfare policy
Title Justice in waiting: The harms and wrongs of temporary refugee protection
URI https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/1474885120973578
https://www.proquest.com/docview/2739025484
Volume 22
hasFullText 1
inHoldings 1
isFullTextHit
isPrint
link http://utb.summon.serialssolutions.com/2.0.0/link/0/eLvHCXMwjV3dS8MwED_m9uKLzC-cTsmDCD7EtWuatr7IEMcQJiobzqfStOnYwzrZVob_vXdr6vxA8KmlKWm4XHq_3F1-B3CupW0HseVzXwaaCzuSPBCp5jLxVDtJlVs43PoPsjcU9yN3VIGsPAtjJLi4orQqHNH6Z02rm7zRLRNkbNnCQ8Vz6dynR3QtN_lyGhbe7rKoBj2h8HQ-pch2TPmQ77w83bYFtbaHhqoKtU73-WXwuUUzeXbUP6cPbAKbv7753ZBt0OmXhLC1jerWYceAS9YptGEXKjrbg7pJccMGs5D3oWeKeLFJxlbRhFKfrxlqDCMi6wWLsoSt5rNsvGCzlH2yVzEcRD7WmhlyB5zSAxh27wa3PW5qKvDYce0lT5UVJ6g9PgIjGRB7oPIjhUZKOpbyVJpaKkHIhPs-z6V7Ckz7ltOOXEc4QvrOIVSzWaaPgNkaF1hkJwlOq4gQeCSpDNwI51vEuE2RDbgsBRS-FdQZoW3YxX8KswHNUoJhqQIhIisKggpfNOCCpLpp-quf4_--eALbVDi-cKY0obqc5_oU4cVSnRmdoOvr41P_A4LpyTQ
link.rule.ids 314,780,784,21966,27853,27924,27925,44945,45333
linkProvider SAGE Publications
linkToHtml http://utb.summon.serialssolutions.com/2.0.0/link/0/eLvHCXMwjV07T8MwED5BO8CCyksUCnhASAxGCXGchK1CVAHaDqgV3SI7tqsuKepD_fucG_cBCIktkh-y7s657-zzdwA3mvt-knsxjXmiKfMFpwkzmnIVyQdlZFgeuHW6PO2z10E42Cr15SQ4vbdpVbii5c96vbvtO3EWoc2F9slnZJladqHKELKgiVebrfeP3jracilztj-1AzZ3lL_m-O6TNkBzK7dr6W5aNThwOJE0S8Uewo4ujqDmstWwwe3JY0hdPS4yKshCjGwW8yNB5RPLST0lolBkMRkXwykZG7ImoiK4iPlQa-J4GlA7J9BvPfeeUurKI9A8CP0ZNdLLFRpCjBiHJ5YIUMZCor_hgScjaYwnFaIfDOGi0H7bO-bYCx5EGLCA8Tg4hUoxLvQZEF_jXhG-UqghJhBDKMOTUKDqWI4RB6_D3UpA2WfJgpH5jij8pzDr0FhJMFtpM0OQZO8zWczqcGulumn6a57z_3a8hr2012ln7Zfu2wXs23rw5RlJAyqzyVxfImqYyStnH18M8rTr
linkToPdf http://utb.summon.serialssolutions.com/2.0.0/link/0/eLvHCXMwjV1LSwMxEB60BfEi9YXVqjmI4GF1002yu96KutRXEWmxt2XTJKWXbemD_n0n3bT1geBtIQ_CzGTnm8zkC8CFFpTGPT_yIhFrj9FMeDEz2hMqlHVlJC8O3F5botlhT13edbU59i6Mk-Dk2pZV4YoWP2u7u0fK3Lgc4w1lIdodt9c-Q8vWsgllxmLGS1BuJO8f7VXE5crmbH_PDljnKX_N8d0vrcHml_quhctJKrDjsCJpFMrdhQ2d70HFVaxhg9uX-9B0b3KRQU7m2cBWMt8SNABieaknJMsVmY-HeX9ChoasyKgILmLW15o4rgbU0AF0kof2XdNzTyR4vYDTqWek31NoDBHiHBFbMkAZZRJ9jgh8GUpjfKkQAWEYF3L7bfPMkR_UMx6wgIkoOIRSPsz1ERCqcb9kVCnUEssQRygjYp6h-lgPow5RhaulgNJRwYSRUkcW_lOYVagtJZguNZoiULI5TRaxKlxaqa6b_prn-L8dz2Hr7T5JXx5bzyewbZ-EL45JalCajmf6FIHDVJ458_gEC2i2BA
openUrl ctx_ver=Z39.88-2004&ctx_enc=info%3Aofi%2Fenc%3AUTF-8&rfr_id=info%3Asid%2Fsummon.serialssolutions.com&rft_val_fmt=info%3Aofi%2Ffmt%3Akev%3Amtx%3Ajournal&rft.genre=article&rft.atitle=Justice+in+waiting%3A+The+harms+and+wrongs+of+temporary+refugee+protection&rft.jtitle=European+journal+of+political+theory&rft.au=Buxton%2C+Rebecca&rft.date=2023-01-01&rft.pub=Sage+Publications+Ltd&rft.issn=1474-8851&rft.eissn=1741-2730&rft.volume=22&rft.issue=1&rft.spage=51&rft.epage=72&rft_id=info:doi/10.1177%2F1474885120973578&rft.externalDBID=NO_FULL_TEXT
thumbnail_l http://covers-cdn.summon.serialssolutions.com/index.aspx?isbn=/lc.gif&issn=1474-8851&client=summon
thumbnail_m http://covers-cdn.summon.serialssolutions.com/index.aspx?isbn=/mc.gif&issn=1474-8851&client=summon
thumbnail_s http://covers-cdn.summon.serialssolutions.com/index.aspx?isbn=/sc.gif&issn=1474-8851&client=summon