Uncertainty quantifications of Pareto optima in multiobjective problems

• Published in: Journal of intelligent manufacturing Vol. 24; no. 2; pp. 385 - 395
• Main Authors: Hung, Tzu-Chieh, Chan, Kuei-Yuan
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Boston Springer US 01.04.2013; Springer Nature B.V
• Subjects: Advanced manufacturing technologies; Approximation; Approximation method; Business and Management; Control; Decision making; Design; Design optimization; Engineering; Industrial engineering; Machines; Manufacturing; Manufacturing industry; Mechatronics; Noise; Numerical analysis; Objectives; Pareto optimum; Processes; Production; Robotics; Structural engineering; Studies; Uncertainty propagation; Multi-objective problems; Pareto set; Design under uncertainty
• DOI: 10.1007/s10845-011-0602-9
• ISSN: 0956-5515

Design is a multi-objective decision-making process considering manufacturing, cost, aesthetics, usability among many other product attributes. The set of optimal solutions, the Pareto set, indicates the trade-offs between objectives. Decision-makers generally select their own optima from the Pareto set based on personal preferences or other judgements. However, uncertainties from manufacturing processes and from operating conditions will change the performances of the Pareto optima. Evaluating the impacts of uncertainties on Pareto optima requires a large amount of data and resources. Comparing multiple Pareto solutions under uncertainty are also very costly. In this work, local Pareto set approximation is integrated with uncertainty propagation technique to quantify design variations in the objective space. An optimality influence range is proposed using linear combinations of objective functions that creates a more accurate polygon objective variation subspace. A set of ‘virtual samples’ is then generated to form two quantifications of the objective variation subspace, namely an influence noise to indicate how a design remains optimal, and an influence range that quantifies the overall variations of a design. In most engineering practices, a Pareto optimum with a smaller influence noise and a smaller influence range is preferred. We also extend the influence noise/range concept to nonlinear Pareto set with the second-order approximation. The quadratic local Pareto approximation method in the literature is also extended in this work to solve multi-objective engineering problems with black-box functions. The usefulness of the proposed quantification method is demonstrated using a numerical example as well as using an engineering problem in structural design.