Humanness and Harmony: Thad Metz on Ubuntu

In this paper I present a critique of some aspects of Thad Metz's attempt to develop an African moral theory grounded on the value of ubuntu. I question the sense in which this theory is African, as well as his attempt to ground human rights on his single value theory of ubuntu. In a number of...

Full description

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Published inPhilosophical papers (Grahamstown) Vol. 51; no. 2; pp. 203 - 237
Main Author Allais, Lucy
Format Journal Article
LanguageEnglish
Published Routledge 04.05.2022
Online AccessGet full text

Cover

Abstract In this paper I present a critique of some aspects of Thad Metz's attempt to develop an African moral theory grounded on the value of ubuntu. I question the sense in which this theory is African, as well as his attempt to ground human rights on his single value theory of ubuntu. In a number of publications Thad Metz has given a clear, analytic account of what ubuntu is. Metz's work on ubuntu does two things: 1) explains the content of ubuntu: what the value/virtue is; 2) presents a moral theory according to which appealing to ubuntu as a basic value enables us to explain what makes all actions right or wrong. He calls this an African moral theory. It is the second part I am skeptical about. He makes it plausible that ubuntu is an important value. And he shows how we can give it some clear content. However, I argue that he does not make plausible a single-value ethical theory based on ubuntu; it is not plausible as an ethical theory, and it is not plausible that such a theory is African in any significant sense.
AbstractList In this paper I present a critique of some aspects of Thad Metz's attempt to develop an African moral theory grounded on the value of ubuntu. I question the sense in which this theory is African, as well as his attempt to ground human rights on his single value theory of ubuntu. In a number of publications Thad Metz has given a clear, analytic account of what ubuntu is. Metz's work on ubuntu does two things: 1) explains the content of ubuntu: what the value/virtue is; 2) presents a moral theory according to which appealing to ubuntu as a basic value enables us to explain what makes all actions right or wrong. He calls this an African moral theory. It is the second part I am skeptical about. He makes it plausible that ubuntu is an important value. And he shows how we can give it some clear content. However, I argue that he does not make plausible a single-value ethical theory based on ubuntu; it is not plausible as an ethical theory, and it is not plausible that such a theory is African in any significant sense.
Author Allais, Lucy
Author_xml – sequence: 1
  givenname: Lucy
  surname: Allais
  fullname: Allais, Lucy
  email: Lucy.Allais@wits.ac.za, LAllais1@jhu.edu
  organization: University of the Witwatersrand and Johns Hopkins University
BookMark eNp9j01LxDAYhIOs4O7qTxB6Frq-aT5MPCmLWmHFy-45pE2ClTaRpEXqr7dl16uXGRhmBp4VWvjgLULXGDYYBNwCY1xwijcFFMUkTDIqztASS8lzwQqyQMu5k8-lC7RK6ROAEoHJEt2UQ6e9tyll2pus1LELfrzP9h_aZG-2_8mCzw7V4PvhEp073SZ7dfI1Ojw_7bdlvnt_ed0-7vKaYOhzVoG0TFNRSG5d5Ri9oxykJBUw6hwxBVhDHUBducpIQggwMDUYPKWUG7JG7Phbx5BStE59xabTcVQY1Ays_oDVDKxOwNPu4bhrvAux098htkb1emxDdFH7ukmK_H_xC-jGXS0
CitedBy_id crossref_primary_10_1080_17533171_2023_2274175
crossref_primary_10_1111_phil_12335
Cites_doi 10.1177/0392192113493737
10.4314/sajpem.v26i4.31493
10.4314/sajpem.v26i4.31492
10.1111/j.1467-9760.2007.00280.x
10.1080/14754830903530300
10.4314/sajpem.v26i4.31490
10.25159/2413-3086/1987
10.4314/sajpem.v26i4.31491
10.1080/02580136.2013.817637
10.1093/acprof:oso/9780190245412.001.0001
10.1111/j.1478-0542.2006.00352.x
10.2307/j.ctv224tvwm.10
10.1080/02580136.2015.1035857
10.1017/S0021853711000223
10.1080/05568641.2018.1544033
10.1080/02580136.2016.1247247
10.1093/hrlr/ngq055
10.1007/s12142-011-0200-4
10.1080/05568641.2017.1295616
10.1080/00131857.2014.991502
10.2979/africatoday.66.1.05
10.1080/19962126.2005.11865140
10.1111/j.1540-5842.1999.tb00012.x
10.1080/19962126.2005.11865150
10.1007/s11217-011-9267-2
10.1093/oso/9780198812838.001.0001
10.5195/JFFP.2016.759
10.4314/sajpem.v26i4.31495
ContentType Journal Article
Copyright 2022 The Editorial Board, Philosophical Papers 2022
Copyright_xml – notice: 2022 The Editorial Board, Philosophical Papers 2022
DBID AAYXX
CITATION
DOI 10.1080/05568641.2022.2059548
DatabaseName CrossRef
DatabaseTitle CrossRef
DatabaseTitleList
DeliveryMethod fulltext_linktorsrc
Discipline Philosophy
EISSN 1996-8523
EndPage 237
ExternalDocumentID 10_1080_05568641_2022_2059548
2059548
Genre Articles
GroupedDBID -ET
-~X
.7I
.QK
0BK
0R~
2DF
3YN
4.4
AAAVI
AACJB
AAGZJ
AAMFJ
AAMIU
AAPUL
AATTQ
AAZMC
ABBKH
ABCCR
ABCCY
ABFIM
ABJVF
ABLIJ
ABPEM
ABPTX
ABQHQ
ABSSG
ABTAI
ABXUL
ACGFO
ACGFS
ACLSK
ACTIO
ACTOA
ADAHI
ADCVX
AECIN
AEGXH
AEGYZ
AEISY
AEKEX
AEOZL
AEPSL
AEYOC
AEZRU
AFOLD
AFWLO
AGDLA
AGMYJ
AGRBW
AIAGR
AIJEM
AKBVH
ALMA_UNASSIGNED_HOLDINGS
ALQZU
AVBZW
BEJHT
BLEHA
BMOTO
BOHLJ
CCCUG
CQ1
DGFLZ
DKSSO
EBS
E~B
E~C
FUNRP
G-F
GTTXZ
H13
HF~
HZ~
IPNFZ
J.O
KDLKA
KYCEM
LJTGL
M4Z
NA5
NV0
O9-
P2P
RIG
RNANH
ROSJB
RSYQP
S-F
SJN
STATR
TEA
TFH
TFL
TFW
TN5
TNTFI
TRJHH
UT5
UT9
V1K
~01
~S~
.4H
AAYXX
ABJNI
ABXYU
ADKVQ
ADMHG
AHDZW
AWYRJ
CITATION
EHI
HMHOC
TBQAZ
TDBHL
TUROJ
ID FETCH-LOGICAL-c310t-5b09e5a48296efbf547460993b054ff3d20ed4f00cbfbd9333050dc0d1d4f46d3
ISSN 0556-8641
IngestDate Fri Dec 06 03:02:58 EST 2024
Tue Jul 04 18:18:03 EDT 2023
IsPeerReviewed true
IsScholarly true
Issue 2
Language English
LinkModel OpenURL
MergedId FETCHMERGED-LOGICAL-c310t-5b09e5a48296efbf547460993b054ff3d20ed4f00cbfbd9333050dc0d1d4f46d3
PageCount 35
ParticipantIDs informaworld_taylorfrancis_310_1080_05568641_2022_2059548
crossref_primary_10_1080_05568641_2022_2059548
PublicationCentury 2000
PublicationDate 2022-05-04
PublicationDateYYYYMMDD 2022-05-04
PublicationDate_xml – month: 05
  year: 2022
  text: 2022-05-04
  day: 04
PublicationDecade 2020
PublicationTitle Philosophical papers (Grahamstown)
PublicationYear 2022
Publisher Routledge
Publisher_xml – name: Routledge
References CIT0030
Ramose Mogobe B. (CIT0031) 1999
CIT0010
CIT0032
CIT0012
CIT1002
CIT0034
Wiredu J. E. (CIT0037) 1997; 75
CIT0033
Allais Lucy. (CIT0001) 2016; 45
Oyowe Oritsegbubemi. (CIT0027) 2013; 13
Park Peter. (CIT0029) 2013
CIT0014
CIT0036
Immanuel Kant (CIT1007) 1998
CIT0013
CIT1003
CIT0035
CIT1006
CIT0016
CIT0038
CIT0018
CIT0017
CIT0039
Oyowe Oritsegbubemi (CIT0028) 2018; 21
CIT0019
CIT0020
CIT0023
CIT0022
Molefe Motsamai. (CIT0025) 2019
Eze E. C. (CIT0007) 2008; 55
Charles W. Mills (CIT1001) 2017
Metz Thaddeus. (CIT0021) 2011; 11
Eze E. C. (CIT0006) 1997
Masolo D. A. (CIT0011) 2010
Elizabeth Thornberry (CIT1004) 2016
CIT0003
CIT0002
CIT0024
Lea Mwambene (CIT1005) 2011; 11
CIT0005
CIT0004
CIT0026
CIT0009
Mbiti John S. (CIT0015) 1990
CIT0008
References_xml – year: 2019
  ident: CIT0025
  publication-title: International Encyclopedia of Ethics
  contributor:
    fullname: Molefe Motsamai.
– volume: 75
  start-page: 320
  year: 1997
  ident: CIT0037
  publication-title: Transition, The Anniversary Issue: Selections from Transition 1961–1976
  contributor:
    fullname: Wiredu J. E.
– ident: CIT0026
  doi: 10.1177/0392192113493737
– volume: 55
  start-page: 77
  issue: 2
  year: 2008
  ident: CIT0007
  publication-title: Africa Today
  contributor:
    fullname: Eze E. C.
– ident: CIT0008
  doi: 10.4314/sajpem.v26i4.31493
– ident: CIT0009
– volume-title: Self and Community in a Changing World
  year: 2010
  ident: CIT0011
  contributor:
    fullname: Masolo D. A.
– ident: CIT0032
  doi: 10.4314/sajpem.v26i4.31492
– ident: CIT0017
  doi: 10.1111/j.1467-9760.2007.00280.x
– volume-title: African Religions & Philosophy
  year: 1990
  ident: CIT0015
  contributor:
    fullname: Mbiti John S.
– ident: CIT0020
  doi: 10.1080/14754830903530300
– ident: CIT0016
  doi: 10.4314/sajpem.v26i4.31490
– ident: CIT0004
  doi: 10.25159/2413-3086/1987
– volume: 13
  start-page: 103
  year: 2013
  ident: CIT0027
  publication-title: African Human Rights Law Journal
  contributor:
    fullname: Oyowe Oritsegbubemi.
– ident: CIT0038
  doi: 10.4314/sajpem.v26i4.31491
– ident: CIT0014
  doi: 10.1080/02580136.2013.817637
– volume-title: Black Rights/White Wrongs
  year: 2017
  ident: CIT1001
  doi: 10.1093/acprof:oso/9780190245412.001.0001
  contributor:
    fullname: Charles W. Mills
– ident: CIT1002
  doi: 10.1111/j.1478-0542.2006.00352.x
– start-page: 137
  volume-title: Marriage by Force? Contestation over Consent and Coercion in Africa
  year: 2016
  ident: CIT1004
  doi: 10.2307/j.ctv224tvwm.10
  contributor:
    fullname: Elizabeth Thornberry
– ident: CIT0012
  doi: 10.1080/02580136.2015.1035857
– ident: CIT1003
  doi: 10.1017/S0021853711000223
– ident: CIT0013
  doi: 10.1080/05568641.2018.1544033
– ident: CIT0002
  doi: 10.1080/02580136.2016.1247247
– volume: 21
  start-page: 343
  year: 2018
  ident: CIT0028
  publication-title: African Philosophical Studies
  contributor:
    fullname: Oyowe Oritsegbubemi
– volume: 11
  start-page: 532
  issue: 2
  year: 2011
  ident: CIT0021
  publication-title: African Human Rights Law Journal
  contributor:
    fullname: Metz Thaddeus.
– volume: 11
  start-page: 1
  issue: 1
  year: 2011
  ident: CIT1005
  publication-title: African Human Rights Law Journal
  doi: 10.1093/hrlr/ngq055
  contributor:
    fullname: Lea Mwambene
– volume-title: Africa, Asia, and the History of Philosophy: Racism in the Formation of the Philosophical Canon 1790–1830
  year: 2013
  ident: CIT0029
  contributor:
    fullname: Park Peter.
– ident: CIT0039
– volume: 45
  start-page: 303
  issue: 1
  year: 2016
  ident: CIT0001
  publication-title: South African Journal of Philosophy
  contributor:
    fullname: Allais Lucy.
– ident: CIT0022
  doi: 10.1007/s12142-011-0200-4
– ident: CIT0005
  doi: 10.1080/05568641.2017.1295616
– ident: CIT0023
  doi: 10.1080/00131857.2014.991502
– ident: CIT0024
  doi: 10.2979/africatoday.66.1.05
– start-page: 313
  volume-title: Postcolonial African Philosophy: A Critical Reader
  year: 1997
  ident: CIT0006
  contributor:
    fullname: Eze E. C.
– ident: CIT0019
  doi: 10.1080/19962126.2005.11865140
– ident: CIT0003
– volume-title: Practical Philosophy
  year: 1998
  ident: CIT1007
  contributor:
    fullname: Immanuel Kant
– ident: CIT0035
  doi: 10.1111/j.1540-5842.1999.tb00012.x
– ident: CIT1006
  doi: 10.1080/19962126.2005.11865150
– ident: CIT0010
  doi: 10.1007/s11217-011-9267-2
– ident: CIT0030
– ident: CIT0034
– ident: CIT0036
  doi: 10.1093/oso/9780198812838.001.0001
– ident: CIT0033
  doi: 10.5195/JFFP.2016.759
– ident: CIT0018
  doi: 10.4314/sajpem.v26i4.31495
– volume-title: African Philosophy through Ubuntu
  year: 1999
  ident: CIT0031
  contributor:
    fullname: Ramose Mogobe B.
SSID ssj0043813
Score 2.2529297
Snippet In this paper I present a critique of some aspects of Thad Metz's attempt to develop an African moral theory grounded on the value of ubuntu. I question the...
SourceID crossref
informaworld
SourceType Aggregation Database
Publisher
StartPage 203
Title Humanness and Harmony: Thad Metz on Ubuntu
URI https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/05568641.2022.2059548
Volume 51
hasFullText 1
inHoldings 1
isFullTextHit
isPrint
link http://utb.summon.serialssolutions.com/2.0.0/link/0/eLvHCXMwpV3NS8MwFA-6XXYRP_GbHjwpHW3zsdabiFKGE5ENditJk4KXOaQ76F_ve026djjEj0soKWna_MLLy-v7_ULIhcjDSJhA-ZTrgc9iHfoyio0fU11ERulQViz-0aNIJ2w45dPmYMiKXVKqfv6xllfyF1ShDnBFluwvkF0-FCrgGvCFEhCG8kcYVxH4ylZh-DuVb9Dzu82jkPpqZMoP_BcwUQtYWNpe6FN9fkGF0FzOkcVbxQuQNg3uIO7MmwgBzBSrRPCwcBLCLkwAO0xMymvChKv5Rda-cC78WFjdqb6x9g9zkmNuKcC1gXSKsC-tfaqzdgFtLZyRVW_5YpNdEiNKnUFnfXw5KDgqzTWL0DI10N3ZJF2UNmQd0h0_D9O0Xl1RkazKGqhfvmZloV76ui5W_I0VNdqWHzHeJltuA-DdWDR3yIaZ7ZLeEpH3PXK5hNUDWD0H67WHoHoIqvc68yyo-2Ryfze-TX13pIWfgx9d-lwFieGSxVEiTKEKzgZMgJNOFbjORUF1FBjNiiDIVaF0QimY40DngQ6hlglND0hn9jozh8RTJpaMqnwQasmkEgmXAmnJ2uCfXcmPSL_-8GxulUuysBaEdSOV4UhlbqSOSNIenqysQkaFPd8lo9-2Pf5H2xPSaybsKemUbwtzBp5eqc4d-J_p10pd
link.rule.ids 314,780,784,27924,27925,59651,60440
linkProvider Taylor & Francis
linkToHtml http://utb.summon.serialssolutions.com/2.0.0/link/0/eLvHCXMwpV1LT8MwDLZgO7ALb8R45sAJKaNtHmu5IcRUxjYh1Em7VUmTCAlpQ1N32H49SR_ShgSXXRu5TR3Hdhz7M8Adz_yAa09iwlQX01D5WAShxiFRJtBS-aKo4h-OeDym_QmbrNXCuLRKd4Y2JVBEoavd5nbB6Dol7sEBwIScuuNd4IqpmEMt24Umizizm7OZfPTjuNbHDsOquGe2RNhR1XU8f71ow0Jt4JeuWZ7eAWT1nMuEk6_OIpedbPULznG7nzqE_coxRU-lJB3Bjp4eQ-u97nSwPIH7IuDvVCOyX0GxmFsRXj6i5FMoNNT5Cs2maCwX1oqdwrj3kjzHuGq1gDPr3-WYSS_STNAwiLg20jDapdw6j0Ral84YogJPK2o8L5NGqogQqyY8lXnKt08pV-QMGtPZVJ8DkjoUlMis6ytBheQRE9yVyyrtbhwFa0OnZm_6XSJqpH4NVFrxIHU8SCsetCFaX4Q0L0IZpuw7kpJ_aS-2oL2FvTgZDtLB6-jtElpuqMh0pFfQyOcLfW29kVzeVOL2A5AV0QA
linkToPdf http://utb.summon.serialssolutions.com/2.0.0/link/0/eLvHCXMwpV3dS8MwED90A9mL3-L87INPQmbbfKz1TdRRpxtDNvCtJE2CIGxjdg_bX2_SNrAJ-rLXlmva6-XukvzudwA3LAtCpnyBMJVtRCIZIB5GCkVY6lAJGfCiir_XZ8mIdD-oQxN-V7BKu4bWJVFE4avt5J5K7RBxd5b_JWLEru5CW0tFLWnZNtSZbZ9cg_rwvZskzh1bCqvimNkIISvlynj-etBagFqjL10JPJ09EO6VS7zJV2uei1a2_MXmuNE37cNulZZ6D6UdHcCWGh9CY-D6HCyO4LbY7reO0TODeAmfGQNe3HvDTy69nsqX3mTsjcTcxLBjGHWeh48JqhotoMxkdzmiwo8V5SQKY6a00JS0CTOpIxYmodMay9BXkmjfz4QWMsbYOAlfZr4MzFXCJD6B2ngyVqfgCRVxgkXWDiQnXLCYcmaLZaWy542cNqHltJtOSz6NNHA0pZUOUquDtNJBE-LVf5DmxUaGLruOpPhf2bMNZK9hZ_DUSd9e-q_n0LB3CpgjuYBaPpurS5OK5OKqMrYfGIfPpA
openUrl ctx_ver=Z39.88-2004&ctx_enc=info%3Aofi%2Fenc%3AUTF-8&rfr_id=info%3Asid%2Fsummon.serialssolutions.com&rft_val_fmt=info%3Aofi%2Ffmt%3Akev%3Amtx%3Ajournal&rft.genre=article&rft.atitle=Humanness+and+Harmony%3A+Thad+Metz+on+Ubuntu&rft.jtitle=Philosophical+papers+%28Grahamstown%29&rft.au=Allais%2C+Lucy&rft.date=2022-05-04&rft.pub=Routledge&rft.issn=0556-8641&rft.eissn=1996-8523&rft.volume=51&rft.issue=2&rft.spage=203&rft.epage=237&rft_id=info:doi/10.1080%2F05568641.2022.2059548&rft.externalDocID=2059548
thumbnail_l http://covers-cdn.summon.serialssolutions.com/index.aspx?isbn=/lc.gif&issn=0556-8641&client=summon
thumbnail_m http://covers-cdn.summon.serialssolutions.com/index.aspx?isbn=/mc.gif&issn=0556-8641&client=summon
thumbnail_s http://covers-cdn.summon.serialssolutions.com/index.aspx?isbn=/sc.gif&issn=0556-8641&client=summon