Aesthetic gestures, moral frameworks: Performing landlessness in Brazil

• Published in: Critique of anthropology Vol. 38; no. 2; pp. 172 - 187
• Main Author: Flynn, Alex
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: London, England SAGE Publications 01.06.2018; Sage Publications Ltd
• Subjects: Aesthetics; Butler, Judith; Ethics; Gestures; Morality; Orderliness; Performativity; Reciprocity; Research subjects; Social activism; Social movements; Territoriality; Time; Transformation; Brazil; Latin America; participation; social movements; Brazil; Performance; aesthetics; Latin America; MST
• DOI: 10.1177/0308275X18758876
• ISSN: 0308-275X

This article, focusing on the Landless Workers’ Movement (MST) of Brazil, demonstrates how members of Latin America’s largest social movement perform the diverse compacts of obligation and reciprocity that characterise an MST occupation. MST encampments seek to enact a transformation of the land on which members are situated, but also emphasise a transformation of the human subject itself, from unproductive to productive. Performing this transformation and becoming truly ‘landless’, however, goes beyond merely being a willing new member: equally as important is the creation and maintenance of an ‘aesthetics of orderliness’ which makes visible the moral connotations that structure or undermine one’s right to become sem terra, landless. Through an analysis that foregrounds the temporality and territoriality of how the MST occupy and drawing a distinction between the precariousness of an MST encampment and the relative stability of an MST settlement, I suggest that movement members are content to perform in the former, but increasingly seek to issue performative acts in the latter. Building on Judith Butler’s distinction between performativity and performance, I argue that individual MST members, embedded in relational spheres, ultimately seek not only to transform themselves but also the wider movement by reconfiguring the very moral framework that structures their social movement from the ground up.