Comment on “Fertilization and pH effects on processes and mechanisms controlling dissolved inorganic phosphorus in soils” by Nicolas
In a recent article by Devau et al. (2011) a mechanistic model based on a surface complexation theory is presented which aims to predict the solubility of inorganic phosphorus (P) in soils. Compared with many empirical soil studies, the surface complexation approach as applied to soils is to be enco...
Saved in:
Published in | Geochimica et cosmochimica acta Vol. 92; pp. 260 - 264 |
---|---|
Main Author | |
Format | Journal Article |
Language | English |
Published |
Elsevier Ltd
01.09.2012
|
Subjects | |
Online Access | Get full text |
Cover
Loading…
Abstract | In a recent article by Devau et al. (2011) a mechanistic model based on a surface complexation theory is presented which aims to predict the solubility of inorganic phosphorus (P) in soils. Compared with many empirical soil studies, the surface complexation approach as applied to soils is to be encouraged since it provides a coherent and mechanistically based foundation for the interpretation of a wide range of soil chemical phenomena. Soil chemists have attempted to explain P solubility for decades, so Devau et al. (2011) have attempted a difficult task but unfortunately they have introduced a number of errors that need to be corrected. The purpose of the present contribution is to suggest some corrections to their proposed model and provide commentary on the errors and inconsistencies concerning the application and citation of the sources of thermodynamic data. Hopefully this will provide some insights for others wishing to progress this subject. |
---|---|
AbstractList | In a recent article by Devau et al. (2011) a mechanistic model based on a surface complexation theory is presented which aims to predict the solubility of inorganic phosphorus (P) in soils. Compared with many empirical soil studies, the surface complexation approach as applied to soils is to be encouraged since it provides a coherent and mechanistically based foundation for the interpretation of a wide range of soil chemical phenomena. Soil chemists have attempted to explain P solubility for decades, so Devau et al. (2011) have attempted a difficult task but unfortunately they have introduced a number of errors that need to be corrected. The purpose of the present contribution is to suggest some corrections to their proposed model and provide commentary on the errors and inconsistencies concerning the application and citation of the sources of thermodynamic data. Hopefully this will provide some insights for others wishing to progress this subject. |
Author | Lumsdon, David G. |
Author_xml | – sequence: 1 givenname: David G. surname: Lumsdon fullname: Lumsdon, David G. email: David.Lumsdon@hutton.ac.uk organization: The James Hutton Institute, Environmental & Biogeochemical Sciences Group, Craigiebuckler, Aberdeen, Scotland AB15 8QH, UK |
BookMark | eNp9kbFuHCEQhlHkSDk7fgBXoUyzG9hl4VapolNsR7KSInGNgJ09c2LhwuxZciqXeQj75fwk5nypUrhAoOH7R5pvjslRTBEIOeOs5ozLT5t67UzdMN7UrKuZaN6QBV-qpuq7tj0iC1agSrFWvSPHiBvGmOo6tiB_V2maIM40Rfp0_3AOefbB_zGzLwUTB7q9pDCO4GbcI9ucHCACvvxN4G5M9DghdSnOOYXg45oOHjGFWxiojymvC-Ho9iZhOXmHpUgx-YBP94_U3tHv3qVg8D15O5qAcPrvPiHX519_rS6rqx8X31ZfrirH-15VRjrLRsegWVrR93IwrbFgYZRqkKLtlWBKSBg6J50ybVOe1jamc1aAGI1tT8jHQ98yyu8d4Kwnjw5CMBHSDjWXatm1Qi5VQdUBdTkhZhi18_OLmTkbHzRneu9eb3Rxr_fuNet0cV-S_L_kNvvJ5LtXMx8OmdEkbdbZo77-WYCurI4LLmQhPh8IKH5uPWSNzkN0MPhcFqSH5F_p_wxIL62E |
CitedBy_id | crossref_primary_10_1016_j_geoderma_2015_08_036 crossref_primary_10_1016_j_gca_2013_03_044 crossref_primary_10_1016_j_apgeochem_2017_10_017 crossref_primary_10_1111_sum_12265 crossref_primary_10_1016_j_geoderma_2017_11_019 crossref_primary_10_1016_j_apgeochem_2014_02_011 crossref_primary_10_1016_j_apgeochem_2014_02_006 crossref_primary_10_1021_es400997n crossref_primary_10_1016_j_apgeochem_2013_03_018 |
Cites_doi | 10.1346/CCMN.1996.0440504 10.1021/es201844d 10.1016/j.jcis.2005.03.060 10.1016/j.apgeochem.2009.09.020 10.1006/jcis.1996.0242 10.1021/es025597s 10.1006/jcis.1999.6448 10.1016/j.gca.2011.02.034 10.1093/aob/mcq098 10.1016/j.jcis.2006.11.022 10.1016/S0021-9797(02)00031-0 10.1016/j.apgeochem.2010.03.008 10.1016/j.gca.2007.09.032 10.1016/j.jcis.2005.11.003 |
ContentType | Journal Article |
Copyright | 2012 Elsevier Ltd |
Copyright_xml | – notice: 2012 Elsevier Ltd |
DBID | FBQ AAYXX CITATION 7S9 L.6 |
DOI | 10.1016/j.gca.2012.05.042 |
DatabaseName | AGRIS CrossRef AGRICOLA AGRICOLA - Academic |
DatabaseTitle | CrossRef AGRICOLA AGRICOLA - Academic |
DatabaseTitleList | AGRICOLA |
Database_xml | – sequence: 1 dbid: FBQ name: AGRIS url: http://www.fao.org/agris/Centre.asp?Menu_1ID=DB&Menu_2ID=DB1&Language=EN&Content=http://www.fao.org/agris/search?Language=EN sourceTypes: Publisher |
DeliveryMethod | fulltext_linktorsrc |
Discipline | Geology |
EISSN | 1872-9533 |
EndPage | 264 |
ExternalDocumentID | 10_1016_j_gca_2012_05_042 US201500114146 S0016703712003523 |
GroupedDBID | --K --M -DZ -~X .~1 0R~ 1B1 1RT 1~. 1~5 4.4 457 4G. 5GY 5VS 7-5 71M 8P~ 9JN AABNK AACTN AAEDT AAEDW AAIAV AAIKJ AAKOC AALRI AAOAW AAQFI AAXUO ABFNM ABMAC ABPPZ ABQEM ABQYD ABXDB ABYKQ ACDAQ ACGFS ACLVX ACRLP ACSBN ADBBV ADEZE ADMUD AEBSH AEKER AENEX AFKWA AFTJW AGHFR AGUBO AGYEJ AHHHB AIEXJ AIKHN AITUG AJBFU AJOXV ALMA_UNASSIGNED_HOLDINGS AMFUW AMRAJ ATOGT AXJTR BKOJK BLXMC CS3 DU5 EBS EFJIC EFLBG EJD EO8 EO9 EP2 EP3 F5P FDB FIRID FNPLU FYGXN G-Q GBLVA HMA HZ~ IHE IMUCA J1W KOM LY3 M41 MO0 N9A O-L O9- OAUVE OZT P-8 P-9 P2P PC. Q38 RIG RNS ROL RPZ SDF SDG SDP SEP SES SPC SSE SSZ T5K TN5 TWZ XSW ZMT ~02 ~G- 29H 6TJ 8WZ A6W AAQXK ABEFU ABPIF ABPTK ADIYS AI. ASPBG AVWKF AZFZN FBQ FEDTE FGOYB G-2 HVGLF MVM OHT R2- SEW UQL VH1 VOH WUQ XJT XOL ZKB AATTM AAXKI AAYWO AAYXX ABJNI ABWVN ACRPL ACVFH ADCNI ADNMO ADXHL AEIPS AEUPX AFJKZ AFPUW AFXIZ AGCQF AGQPQ AGRNS AIGII AIIUN AKBMS AKRWK AKYEP ANKPU BNPGV CITATION SSH 7S9 EFKBS L.6 |
ID | FETCH-LOGICAL-c1997-a6cb0fc0e28b4996da3abebef67d6439740746ed5c6c7a326edbb2a5cb4e4fab3 |
IEDL.DBID | .~1 |
ISSN | 0016-7037 |
IngestDate | Mon Jul 21 10:03:49 EDT 2025 Tue Jul 01 01:33:36 EDT 2025 Thu Apr 24 22:58:08 EDT 2025 Wed Dec 27 19:07:08 EST 2023 Fri Feb 23 02:24:01 EST 2024 |
IsPeerReviewed | true |
IsScholarly | true |
Language | English |
License | https://www.elsevier.com/tdm/userlicense/1.0 |
LinkModel | DirectLink |
MergedId | FETCHMERGED-LOGICAL-c1997-a6cb0fc0e28b4996da3abebef67d6439740746ed5c6c7a326edbb2a5cb4e4fab3 |
Notes | http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.gca.2012.05.042 ObjectType-Article-1 SourceType-Scholarly Journals-1 ObjectType-Feature-2 content type line 23 |
PQID | 1678534687 |
PQPubID | 24069 |
PageCount | 5 |
ParticipantIDs | proquest_miscellaneous_1678534687 crossref_citationtrail_10_1016_j_gca_2012_05_042 crossref_primary_10_1016_j_gca_2012_05_042 fao_agris_US201500114146 elsevier_sciencedirect_doi_10_1016_j_gca_2012_05_042 |
ProviderPackageCode | CITATION AAYXX |
PublicationCentury | 2000 |
PublicationDate | 20120901 |
PublicationDateYYYYMMDD | 2012-09-01 |
PublicationDate_xml | – month: 09 year: 2012 text: 20120901 day: 01 |
PublicationDecade | 2010 |
PublicationTitle | Geochimica et cosmochimica acta |
PublicationYear | 2012 |
Publisher | Elsevier Ltd |
Publisher_xml | – name: Elsevier Ltd |
References | Devau, Hinsinger, Le Cadre, Colomb, Gerard (b0020) 2011; 75 Gu, Evans (b0035) 2008; 72 Duc, Gaboriaud, Thomas (b0025) 2005; 289 Gu, Evans (b0030) 2007; 307 Liu, Sun, Forsling, Du, Tang (b0050) 1999; 219 Hiemstra, Van Riemsdijk (b0040) 1996; 179 Rahnemaie, Hiemstra, Van Riemsdijk (b0065) 2006; 297 Weng, Vega, Van Riemsdijk (b0070) 2011; 45 Devau, Le Cadre, Hinsinger, Jaillard, Gerard (b0005) 2009; 24 Devau, Le Cadre, Hinsinger, Jaillard, Gerard (b0010) 2010; 25 Meeussen (b0055) 2003; 37 Manning, Goldberg (b0060) 1996; 44 Lackovic, Angove, Wells, Johnson (b0045) 2003; 257 Devau, Le Cadre, Hinsinger, Gerard (b0015) 2010; 105 Devau (10.1016/j.gca.2012.05.042_b0020) 2011; 75 Gu (10.1016/j.gca.2012.05.042_b0035) 2008; 72 Liu (10.1016/j.gca.2012.05.042_b0050) 1999; 219 Devau (10.1016/j.gca.2012.05.042_b0005) 2009; 24 Meeussen (10.1016/j.gca.2012.05.042_b0055) 2003; 37 Weng (10.1016/j.gca.2012.05.042_b0070) 2011; 45 Hiemstra (10.1016/j.gca.2012.05.042_b0040) 1996; 179 Devau (10.1016/j.gca.2012.05.042_b0015) 2010; 105 Lackovic (10.1016/j.gca.2012.05.042_b0045) 2003; 257 Devau (10.1016/j.gca.2012.05.042_b0010) 2010; 25 Rahnemaie (10.1016/j.gca.2012.05.042_b0065) 2006; 297 Manning (10.1016/j.gca.2012.05.042_b0060) 1996; 44 Duc (10.1016/j.gca.2012.05.042_b0025) 2005; 289 Gu (10.1016/j.gca.2012.05.042_b0030) 2007; 307 |
References_xml | – volume: 307 start-page: 317 year: 2007 end-page: 325 ident: b0030 article-title: Modelling the adsorption of Cd(II), Cu(II), Ni(II), Pb(II), and Zn(II) onto Fithian illite publication-title: J. Colloid Interface Sci. – volume: 25 start-page: 1094 year: 2010 end-page: 1095 ident: b0010 article-title: Erratum to “Soil pH controls the environmental availability of phosphorus: Experimental and mechanistic modelling approaches” [Appl. Geochem. 24(11), 2163–2174] publication-title: Appl. Geochem. – volume: 37 start-page: 1175 year: 2003 end-page: 1182 ident: b0055 article-title: ORCHESTRA: An object-oriented framework for implementing chemical equilibrium models publication-title: Environ. Sci. Technol. – volume: 24 start-page: 2163 year: 2009 end-page: 2174 ident: b0005 article-title: Soil pH controls the environmental availability of phosphorus: Experimental and mechanistic modelling approaches publication-title: Appl. Geochem. – volume: 179 start-page: 488 year: 1996 end-page: 508 ident: b0040 article-title: A surface structural approach to ion adsorption: The charge distribution (CD) model publication-title: J. Colloid Interface Sci. – volume: 297 start-page: 379 year: 2006 end-page: 388 ident: b0065 article-title: Inner- and outer-sphere complexation of ions at the goethite-solution interface publication-title: J. Colloid Interface Sci. – volume: 45 start-page: 8420 year: 2011 end-page: 8428 ident: b0070 article-title: Competitive and synergistic effects in pH dependent phosphate adsorption in soils: LCD modelling publication-title: Environ. Sci. Technol. – volume: 219 start-page: 48 year: 1999 end-page: 61 ident: b0050 article-title: A comparative study of surface acid-base characteristics of natural illites from different origins publication-title: J. Colloid Interface Sci. – volume: 257 start-page: 31 year: 2003 end-page: 40 ident: b0045 article-title: Modeling the adsorption of Cd(II) onto Muloorina illite and related clay minerals publication-title: J. Colloid Interface Sci. – volume: 289 start-page: 139 year: 2005 end-page: 147 ident: b0025 article-title: Sensitivity of the acid-base properties of clays to the methods of preparation and measurement – 1. Literature review publication-title: J. Colloid Interface Sci. – volume: 72 start-page: 267 year: 2008 end-page: 276 ident: b0035 article-title: Surface complexation modelling of Cd(II), Cu(II), Ni(II), Pb(II) and Zn(II) adsorption onto kaolinite publication-title: Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta – volume: 44 start-page: 609 year: 1996 end-page: 623 ident: b0060 article-title: Modeling arsenate competitive adsorption on kaolinite, montmorillonite and illite publication-title: Clays Clay Miner. – volume: 75 start-page: 2980 year: 2011 end-page: 2996 ident: b0020 article-title: Fertilization and pH effects on processes and mechanisms controlling dissolved inorganic phosphorus in soils publication-title: Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta – volume: 105 start-page: 1183 year: 2010 end-page: 1197 ident: b0015 article-title: A mechanistic model for understanding root-induced chemical changes controlling phosphorus availability publication-title: Ann. Bot. – London – volume: 44 start-page: 609 year: 1996 ident: 10.1016/j.gca.2012.05.042_b0060 article-title: Modeling arsenate competitive adsorption on kaolinite, montmorillonite and illite publication-title: Clays Clay Miner. doi: 10.1346/CCMN.1996.0440504 – volume: 45 start-page: 8420 year: 2011 ident: 10.1016/j.gca.2012.05.042_b0070 article-title: Competitive and synergistic effects in pH dependent phosphate adsorption in soils: LCD modelling publication-title: Environ. Sci. Technol. doi: 10.1021/es201844d – volume: 289 start-page: 139 year: 2005 ident: 10.1016/j.gca.2012.05.042_b0025 article-title: Sensitivity of the acid-base properties of clays to the methods of preparation and measurement – 1. Literature review publication-title: J. Colloid Interface Sci. doi: 10.1016/j.jcis.2005.03.060 – volume: 24 start-page: 2163 year: 2009 ident: 10.1016/j.gca.2012.05.042_b0005 article-title: Soil pH controls the environmental availability of phosphorus: Experimental and mechanistic modelling approaches publication-title: Appl. Geochem. doi: 10.1016/j.apgeochem.2009.09.020 – volume: 179 start-page: 488 year: 1996 ident: 10.1016/j.gca.2012.05.042_b0040 article-title: A surface structural approach to ion adsorption: The charge distribution (CD) model publication-title: J. Colloid Interface Sci. doi: 10.1006/jcis.1996.0242 – volume: 37 start-page: 1175 year: 2003 ident: 10.1016/j.gca.2012.05.042_b0055 article-title: ORCHESTRA: An object-oriented framework for implementing chemical equilibrium models publication-title: Environ. Sci. Technol. doi: 10.1021/es025597s – volume: 219 start-page: 48 year: 1999 ident: 10.1016/j.gca.2012.05.042_b0050 article-title: A comparative study of surface acid-base characteristics of natural illites from different origins publication-title: J. Colloid Interface Sci. doi: 10.1006/jcis.1999.6448 – volume: 75 start-page: 2980 year: 2011 ident: 10.1016/j.gca.2012.05.042_b0020 article-title: Fertilization and pH effects on processes and mechanisms controlling dissolved inorganic phosphorus in soils publication-title: Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta doi: 10.1016/j.gca.2011.02.034 – volume: 105 start-page: 1183 year: 2010 ident: 10.1016/j.gca.2012.05.042_b0015 article-title: A mechanistic model for understanding root-induced chemical changes controlling phosphorus availability publication-title: Ann. Bot. – London doi: 10.1093/aob/mcq098 – volume: 307 start-page: 317 year: 2007 ident: 10.1016/j.gca.2012.05.042_b0030 article-title: Modelling the adsorption of Cd(II), Cu(II), Ni(II), Pb(II), and Zn(II) onto Fithian illite publication-title: J. Colloid Interface Sci. doi: 10.1016/j.jcis.2006.11.022 – volume: 257 start-page: 31 year: 2003 ident: 10.1016/j.gca.2012.05.042_b0045 article-title: Modeling the adsorption of Cd(II) onto Muloorina illite and related clay minerals publication-title: J. Colloid Interface Sci. doi: 10.1016/S0021-9797(02)00031-0 – volume: 25 start-page: 1094 year: 2010 ident: 10.1016/j.gca.2012.05.042_b0010 article-title: Erratum to “Soil pH controls the environmental availability of phosphorus: Experimental and mechanistic modelling approaches” [Appl. Geochem. 24(11), 2163–2174] publication-title: Appl. Geochem. doi: 10.1016/j.apgeochem.2010.03.008 – volume: 72 start-page: 267 year: 2008 ident: 10.1016/j.gca.2012.05.042_b0035 article-title: Surface complexation modelling of Cd(II), Cu(II), Ni(II), Pb(II) and Zn(II) adsorption onto kaolinite publication-title: Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta doi: 10.1016/j.gca.2007.09.032 – volume: 297 start-page: 379 year: 2006 ident: 10.1016/j.gca.2012.05.042_b0065 article-title: Inner- and outer-sphere complexation of ions at the goethite-solution interface publication-title: J. Colloid Interface Sci. doi: 10.1016/j.jcis.2005.11.003 |
SSID | ssj0007550 |
Score | 2.0360174 |
Snippet | In a recent article by Devau et al. (2011) a mechanistic model based on a surface complexation theory is presented which aims to predict the solubility of... |
SourceID | proquest crossref fao elsevier |
SourceType | Aggregation Database Enrichment Source Index Database Publisher |
StartPage | 260 |
SubjectTerms | chemists inorganic phosphorus soil solubility thermodynamics |
Title | Comment on “Fertilization and pH effects on processes and mechanisms controlling dissolved inorganic phosphorus in soils” by Nicolas |
URI | https://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.gca.2012.05.042 https://www.proquest.com/docview/1678534687 |
Volume | 92 |
hasFullText | 1 |
inHoldings | 1 |
isFullTextHit | |
isPrint | |
link | http://utb.summon.serialssolutions.com/2.0.0/link/0/eLvHCXMwnV3BTtwwELWACokLolDEthQZiRNSIMnazu4RoW4XqnKBlbhZtuNAqiWJMIvEpeLIR8DP8SXMOE5RVcGhhxziOE6UmcyM7fdmCNlJMpOAYLOoEAWPWGL60dAYHVmTxqLQTKsY2cg_T8R4wo7P-fkcOey4MAirDLa_teneWoeW_fA195uyRI5vIjLMONcm9cSMn4xlqOV7v19hHhnnLQ0lERH27nY2PcbrwmDqIVwO5HsxS9_yTfOFqv-x1d4BjVbIcogc6UH7ch_JnK1WyeJ3X5n3bo08INUDPAitK_p8_zhCvPQ0kCypqnLajGkAb2CXpiUIWOevXVkkAJfuytGAXUeWOsXN-np6a3NaVm35J0Oby9rBcT1z0EhdXU7d8_0T1XfUK5Vyn8hk9O3scByFMguR8blYlTA6Lkxs04GG-Y_IVV9pkG0hstzHKwxrkticG2EyBeGezbVOFTeaWVYo3V8nC1Vd2Q1Ch3ZguY7zgdIFg5GGlsEMU2nGeApj6R6Juw8sTchBjqUwprIDm_2SIBOJMpExlyCTHtn9c0vTJuB4rzPrpCb_0iIJDuK92zZAwlJdgF2Vk9MUV4FwoghepEe2O7FL-PFwN0VVtp45CcoHoQ4Tg-zz_z31C1nCsxawtkkWbq5n9itEODd6y6vwFvlwcPRjfPICdF79aA |
linkProvider | Elsevier |
linkToHtml | http://utb.summon.serialssolutions.com/2.0.0/link/0/eLvHCXMwnV1Lb9QwEB61WyG4IJ7q8jQSJ6TQJGs7u8eqYklpuxe6Um-W7Tht0DaJ6i5Sbz3yI-DP9ZcwkziVEKIHDrn4lcifMzO255sBeJ9kNkFgs6iUpYh4YifRzFoTOZvGsjTc6JjYyEcLmS_5lxNxsgF7AxeG3CqD7O9leietQ8lOmM2dtqqI45vIjCLO9UE9J5uwRdGpxAi2dvcP8sWtQM6E6JkoiYyow3C52bl5nVqKPkQnguJjzNN_qafNUjd_ietOB80fwcNgPLLd_vsew4arn8C9z11y3qun8IPYHqhEWFOzm-ufc3KZXgWeJdN1wdqcBf8NatL2HAHnu7pzRxzgyp97FtzXiajO6L6-WX13BavqPgOUZe1Z4_G5WHssZL6pVv7m-hczV6xbV9o_g-X80_FeHoVMC5HtwrFqaU1c2tilU4NbIFnoiTYIbymzojNZOKUlcYWw0mYaLT5XGJNqYQ13vNRm8hxGdVO7bWAzN3XCxMVUm5LjSDPHcZOpDecixbHMGOJhgpUNYcgpG8ZKDf5m3xRioggTFQuFmIzhw22Xto_BcVdjPqCm_lhICnXEXd22EWGlT1G0quXXlA6CaK-IimQM7wbYFf57dKGia9esvcL1h9YOl9Psxf-99S3cz4-PDtXh_uLgJTygmt5_7RWMLi_W7jUaPJfmTVjQvwEaQAAo |
openUrl | ctx_ver=Z39.88-2004&ctx_enc=info%3Aofi%2Fenc%3AUTF-8&rfr_id=info%3Asid%2Fsummon.serialssolutions.com&rft_val_fmt=info%3Aofi%2Ffmt%3Akev%3Amtx%3Ajournal&rft.genre=article&rft.atitle=Comment+on+%E2%80%9CFertilization+and+pH+effects+on+processes+and+mechanisms+controlling+dissolved+inorganic+phosphorus+in+soils%E2%80%9D+by+Nicolas&rft.jtitle=Geochimica+et+cosmochimica+acta&rft.au=Lumsdon%2C+David+G.&rft.date=2012-09-01&rft.issn=0016-7037&rft.volume=92&rft.spage=260&rft.epage=264&rft_id=info:doi/10.1016%2Fj.gca.2012.05.042&rft.externalDBID=n%2Fa&rft.externalDocID=10_1016_j_gca_2012_05_042 |
thumbnail_l | http://covers-cdn.summon.serialssolutions.com/index.aspx?isbn=/lc.gif&issn=0016-7037&client=summon |
thumbnail_m | http://covers-cdn.summon.serialssolutions.com/index.aspx?isbn=/mc.gif&issn=0016-7037&client=summon |
thumbnail_s | http://covers-cdn.summon.serialssolutions.com/index.aspx?isbn=/sc.gif&issn=0016-7037&client=summon |