Arthroscopic modified Broström may improve function while anatomic reconstructions could enhance stability for chronic lateral ankle instability: A network meta-analysis

• Published in: Foot and ankle surgery
• Main Authors: Tsai, Chun-Sheng, Huang, Ming-Tung, Jou, I.-Ming, Wu, Po-Ting, Ko, Po-Yen
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: France Elsevier Ltd 26.05.2024
• Subjects: Anatomic reconstruction; Arthroscopic modified Broström technique; Chronic lateral ankle instability; Network meta-analysis; Open modified Broström technique; Suture tape augmentation; Suture tape augmentation; Anatomic reconstruction; Network meta-analysis; Open modified Broström technique; Arthroscopic modified Broström technique; Chronic lateral ankle instability
• ISSN: 1268-7731; 1460-9584
• DOI: 10.1016/j.fas.2024.05.008

The purpose of this systematic review and network meta-analysis was to compare the efficacy of different surgical treatments, including open and arthroscopic modified Broström procedures (MB), anatomical reconstructions, and suture tape augmentations (STA), for chronic lateral ankle instability (CLAI). We conducted a systematic search for comparative studies that included adult patients with CLAI who underwent open MB, arthroscopic MB, reconstruction with autografts or allografts, and STA. We used a random-effects model to present the NMA results, with mean differences and 95 % confidence intervals (CI) for continuous measures and relative ratios with 95 % CI for dichotomous variables. Surface under the cumulative ranking curve analysis (SUCRA) was used for treatment ranking. The results, based on surface under the cumulative ranking curve analysis, showed that arthroscopic MB likely improves functional outcomes the most as measured by change in American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society (AOFAS) ankle-hindfoot scores. Anatomical graft reconstructions with allografts or autografts demonstrated greater reduction in anterior talar translation (ATT) and talar tilt angle (TTA). Arthroscopic MB and STA were associated with fewer complications. Arthroscopic MB may be associated with better functional outcomes, while anatomical reconstructions appear to provide greater improvements in stability for CLAI. Additionally, arthroscopic techniques seem to have lower complication risks compared to open procedures. These potential differences in outcomes and risks between techniques could help guide surgical decision-making.