Evaluating performance of simplified physically based models for shallow landslide susceptibility

• Published in: Hydrology and earth system sciences Vol. 20; no. 11; pp. 4585 - 4603
• Main Authors: Formetta, Giuseppe, Capparelli, Giovanna, Versace, Pasquale
• Format: Journal Article
• Language: English
• Published: Katlenburg-Lindau Copernicus GmbH 15.11.2016; Copernicus Publications
• Subjects: Algorithms; Analysis; Calibration; Case studies; Climatic analysis; Climatology; Discriminant analysis; Geographic information systems; Geographical information systems; Geology; Geomorphology; Goodness of fit; Hydrogeology; Hydrologic models; Hydrology; Information systems; Landslides; Landslides & mudslides; Mathematical models; Multivariate analysis; Parameter estimation; Performance assessment; Performance evaluation; Performance testing; Pixels; Rain; Rainfall; Remote sensing; Sensitivity analysis; Statistical analysis; Statistical methods; Transportation systems; Verification; Italy
• ISSN: 1607-7938; 1027-5606; 1607-7938
• DOI: 10.5194/hess-20-4585-2016

Rainfall-induced shallow landslides can lead to loss of life and significant damage to private and public properties, transportation systems, etc. Predicting locations that might be susceptible to shallow landslides is a complex task and involves many disciplines: hydrology, geotechnical science, geology, hydrogeology, geomorphology, and statistics. Two main approaches are commonly used: statistical or physically based models. Reliable model applications involve automatic parameter calibration, objective quantification of the quality of susceptibility maps, and model sensitivity analyses. This paper presents a methodology to systemically and objectively calibrate, verify, and compare different models and model performance indicators in order to identify and select the models whose behavior is the most reliable for particular case studies.The procedure was implemented in a package of models for landslide susceptibility analysis and integrated in the NewAge-JGrass hydrological model. The package includes three simplified physically based models for landslide susceptibility analysis (M1, M2, and M3) and a component for model verification. It computes eight goodness-of-fit indices by comparing pixel-by-pixel model results and measurement data. The integration of the package in NewAge-JGrass uses other components, such as geographic information system tools, to manage input–output processes, and automatic calibration algorithms to estimate model parameters. The system was applied for a case study in Calabria (Italy) along the Salerno–Reggio Calabria highway, between Cosenza and Altilia. The area is extensively subject to rainfall-induced shallow landslides mainly because of its complex geology and climatology. The analysis was carried out considering all the combinations of the eight optimized indices and the three models. Parameter calibration, verification, and model performance assessment were performed by a comparison with a detailed landslide inventory map for the area. The results showed that the index distance to perfect classification in the receiver operating characteristic plane (D2PC) coupled with the model M3 is the best modeling solution for our test case.